It could be argued that Susan Crossley (née Dean) has been unlucky in love, but no one would say that she didn’t marry well.

Her first two husbands were Kevin Nicholson, heir to the Kwik Save fortune, and Peter Lilley, the adopted son of Thomas Lilley, chief of Lilley and Skinner shoes.

Her third husband was the racing magnate Robert Sangster, heir to the Vernon Pools fortune. That marriage, too, ended in divorce, in 2000, and a generous settlement, of £16 million.

So when she and husband number four, worth £45 million, decided to part ways he must have been pleased that he had secured a prenuptial agreement in which she promised that she would not pursue his fortune.

After all, their union lasted only 14 months, and much of this time had been spent apart.

But Mrs Crossley, 50, is not a woman to take her marriage vows lightly. She married Stuart Crossley, 62, for richer or for poorer and she claims that he has £60 million in accounts in Monaco and Andorra that she did not know about when she signed the prenuptial agreement.

That, she claimed, rendered their agreement invalid.

Mr Crossley’s legal team had asked the courts to short-circuit normal divorce procedures because the marriage was short and childless, both partners had independent wealth and a prenuptial agreement was in place.

In that document the couple had agreed that in the event of a divorce they would retain their own assets and make no claims against each other.

His team argued that the facts could be heard in one day rather than enduring the usual proceedings, which might entail three hearings, a delay of up to 18 months and significant costs.

The High Court judge Mr Justice Bennett agreed that the case could be heard in one day in February, when the prenuptial agreement would be evaluated and a decision made there and then over whether to throw out Mrs Crossley’s arguments..

Yesterday, Mrs Crossley’s legal team argued that in agreeing such a procedure Mr Justice Bennett was denying her access to the courts. She would have no chance to present evidence about undisclosed assets that she claimed rendered the agreement invalid.

Her appeal was dismissed by three Court of Appeal judges.

Lord Justice Thorpe, who sat with Lords Justices Keene and Wall, praised Mr Justice Bennett’s innovative decision and said that judges had a duty to look at ways to shorten the trial process where “very rich people are demanding full-scale trials” and limiting the courts’ overstretched capacity.

Lord Justice Thorpe, giving the ruling, also called for legislation to clarify the status of prenuptial agreements. In Britain they are not legally binding, although judges do take them into account.

He said: “This is a quite exceptional case on its facts. If ever there is to be a paradigm case in which the courts will look to the prenuptial agreement as not simply one of the peripheral factors of the case but a factor of magnetic importance, then it seems to me that this is such a case.”

There was a “strong argument” for legislation, he added, given that the European Union considered it important to tackle the differences that existed on property-sharing between member states.

Mark Harper, a partner with Mr Crossley’s solicitors, said that the ruling was “a significant step forward for prenuptial agreements”. He added: “The Court of Appeal has shown that when a prenuptial agreement exists, the English courts can take a pragmatic approach and short-circuit normal court procedures, saving time, money and emotional distress for all involved.”

Mr Crossley said: “This is a fair decision. I am upset that our marriage failed.”

He met his future wife in the summer of 2005 and they were married 14 weeks later, in early January last year. But from June the couple lived largely separate lives and in August she filed for divorce.

Married life

— Susan Crossley was born Susan Dean on the Isle of Man, to wealthy parents. Her mother ran a nursery school; her father was a timber merchant. She was educated at Buchan School, a preparatory school on the island.

— At 18, the aspiring model married Kevin Nicholson heir to the Kwik Save fortune. They divorced after 18 months.

— She then married Peter Lilley, the adopted son of Thomas Lilley, chief of Lilley and Skinner shoes. They divorced in 1984

— She had very public affair with racehorse magnate, and the heir to the Vernon pools fortune, Robert Sangster after his very public affair with Jerry Hall. He was married to Australian socialite Susan Peacock at the time.They married in 1985 and divorced in 2000.

Source: Times archive

Explore Law

• Public Law

• Corporate Law

• Columnists

• Student Law

• Law Reports

• Law Panel

Times Recommends

• Judges give up wigs in a case of modernisation
• ‘Paraffin mafia’ comes unstuck after €676m fines
• Total 'is ducking blame for fuel blast'