Andrew Sullivan
Your last chance to get tickets to Top Gear Live
What do you do if you are a conservative in a party whose brand has become synonymous with nastiness, xenophobia, homo-phobia, narcissism and incompetence? You could ask William Hague that question. Or Iain Duncan Smith. Or Michael Howard. Or you could ask David Cameron. And it appears that the Republican nominee for the presidency, John McCain – at least metaphorically – has.
As McCain repositions himself as a centrist independent for the election, it is very hard not to think of the Tory struggle these past 10 years. In fact, it’s helpful to think of McCain’s attempt to reach to the centre of American politics as Cameronism Americanised. Or, to coin a phrase: McCameronism.
Cameron, of course, has one huge advantage over McCain – and not just the hair. The bad memories of the last years of Tory rule have diminished over the past decade and even come to contaminate the other party, Labour.
McCain has no such luxury. The Republican brand has rarely been this weak and guilt by association with it this strong.
Gallup’s polling shows that George W Bush is now more damaging to McCain than the firebrand pastor Jere-miah Wright is to Barack Obama. On broader, more stable polling measurements, you will find a historic low in the numbers of people identifying as Republicans and a historically high lead for Democrats of about 10%.
To put this in perspective the Democrats’ lead on the eve of the 2006 election, when Republicans were routed in the Congress, was 6%.
We’re talking landslide potential here: and many are now predicting a Democratic majority in the next House of Representatives of about 70 and a majority of 10 in the Senate. In the younger generation, the Republican brand is even less popular. Last Tuesday saw the third congressional by-election in a very safe Republican seat go to the Democrats – this time in northern Mississippi, no less. For good measure, an all-time record of 82% of Americans believe the country is on the “wrong track”.
Into this brutal landscape for a Republican McCain has already done several clear things to differentiate himself from his party’s brand.
The first should be familiar to those who have studied the Tory modernis-ers in Britain. McCain went green.
Last week, he unveiled his own support for a “cap-and-trade” carbon emissions regime just a mite less onerous than Obama’s. Implicitly, he scorched the current president’s en-vironmental record by saying that he would not stand by and let America do nothing while issues such as climate change dominate global discussion.
“We stand warned by serious and credible scientists across the world that time is short and the dangers are great,” McCain intoned. “The most relevant question now is whether our own government is equal to the challenge.”
He maintained his opposition to drilling for oil in the protected part of Alaska. He went on a green photo-opportunity in the Mountain West. And he even unveiled a green McCain logo, with a recycling symbol on it.
Next, he pledged last Thursday to bring most of the troops home from Iraq by the end of his first term. In a slightly strange speech premised on the notion of McCain looking back on his first (and only?) term, McCain predicted: “By January 2013 America has welcomed home most of the service-men and women who have sacrificed terribly so that America might be secure in her freedom . . . The United States maintains a military presence there, but a much smaller one, and it does not play a direct combat role.”
What he’s clearly trying to do is construct the autumn debate so that the major difference between the two candidates is not who will get the US out of Iraq, but the manner in which each will do it. Good luck.
McCain has also broken with Republican orthodoxy on two central questions: immigration reform, where he is much closer to the Democrats than to his own party base; and torture, where he has pledged to end the current administration’s violation of common article 3 of the Geneva conventions.
On both these issues he is not just alienating the core base of the Republican party, he is enraging it. And part of that rage comes from a fearful sense that McCain’s Cameronite message could work.
Last week Rush Limbaugh, the right-wing talkshow host, bemoaned: “It’s entirely possible this newly constituted Republican party, which stands for nothing but liberalism lite, might end up winning because a lot of the country might look at this socialist bunch the Democrats are offering and say pooey, and want no part of it, and then where are we?”
Well, you’re with a Republican president intent on remaking the Republican brand: that’s where you are. And it doesn’t make everyone happy. One of the more ferocious Republican blog-gers on the web, Michelle Malkin, summed up a lot of the base feelings: “I don’t want a Republican presidential nominee who sneers about profits like Ralph Nader. I don’t want a Republican presidential nominee who talks and walks like Al Gore. And as I’ve said before in response to the annoying McCain platitudes about ‘reaching across the aisle’ and ‘getting things done’ . . . ‘Get things done’ is mindless liberal code for passing legislation and expanding government.”
If this kind of sentiment reminds you of Lord Tebbit on Cameron, you’re not far off. The difference is that McCain is the elder statesman and Malkin a whippersnapper.
McCain also understands that part of the Republican problem, especially after Hurricane Katrina, is a widespread notion that it is unconnected to many minority voters, especially African-Americans and Hispanics who make up a growing segment of the voting public.
McCain’s long record with Latinos in his home border state of Arizona gives him an opening here. But he knows he has his work cut out for him. So he also did a classic Cameron gambit recently and spent a week touring parts of “forgotten America”, parts where poverty and racial diversity are the norm.
As Tim Pawlenty, the young Republican governor of Minnesota, noted recently: “The country is changing. The Republican party has to have a message that reflects faces and voices of America. We have to do a better job of recruiting women candidates, candidates of colour and diversity.” Pawlenty, by the way, is often spoken of as a vice-presidential pick for McCain.
Yes, Bush paid lip service to diversity and had two African-American secretaries of state. But his immigration plans collapsed after a revolt in his own party, his antigay positions alienated him from the more inclusive younger generation and Hurricane Katrina and those scenes from New Orleans killed his small gains among black voters.
McCain, moreover, is up against more than Bush was four years ago. He will almost certainly have to confront a black Democratic rival whose closest competitor was a woman. The danger is that disaffection with the Republican brand and a huge wave of young, black and Latino voters could become an electoral tsunami crushing the Republicans in November.
So McCameronism is the new product. And McCain, who was one of the few American Republicans to visit the young Tory leader before he was riding high in the polls, is trying to follow the British lead.
It’s harder. McCain hasn’t even begun to overhaul his party – and will have to run for office by both disowning and coopting it at the same time, not an easy task.
If elected, he will have to govern as an independent, triangulating away from what is almost certain to be a large Democratic majority in both Houses of Congress.
But this is the only chance he’ll ever get. And if he has to learn a thing or two from a British fortysomething, he’s happy to do so. From Thatcher, we got Reagan. From Cameron, McCain? Unforeseen, for sure. But so has almost everything important that has happened in this election so far.

Andrew Sullivan is an author, academic and journalist. He holds a PhD from Harvard in political science, and is a former editor of The New Republic. His 1995 book, Virtually Normal: An Argument About Homosexuality, became one of the best-selling books on gay rights. He has been a regular columnist for The Sunday Times since the 1990s, and also writes for Time and other publications.
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Las Vegas SALE!
£POA
With Ramblers Worldwide Holidays!
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - search houses for sale and rooms and property to rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Appointing two black secretaries of state - no other president has appointed even one - is hardly "lip service". Also, you are misinformed about so many matters that I can't list them all. I recommend boning up on current events before publicly posting again.
Joyce, Atlanta, GA,
Although I am a Republican sympathizer, I am well aware that 2008 will be the Democrats' revenge for the 1984 Reagan-Mondale blowout. President Bush has virtually ensured this type of electoral disaster by invading Iraq without cause; a poor Hurricane Katrina response, and by ignorin global warming
Andre, Portland,ME, USA
Hilarious that you should quote Tim Pawlenty on the value of diversity. Here's a governor who supported an amendment to the Minnesota state constitution against same-sex marriage and demagogues on immigration at every opportunity. Republicans are afraid of the "other." They just can't help themselve
Paul G., Minneapolis, MN,
McCain has two massive problems, which I hope will sink him in November:
1) the more he alienates the anti-global-warming, anti-gay marriage GOP base, the less likely they are to turn out and support him, and
2) he doesn't appear to have a clue how to tackle the economic and healthcare crises.
Simon Buckland, washington, dc, USA
It's remarkable that the only guy in the Republican party who remotely understands what the world needs from America is a septuagenarian. All those who cling to the idea that climate change isn't real are dinosaurs, and will hopefully go the same way!
Dr Richard Milne, Edinburgh,
The point is th erepublicans may understand they are unelectable, or the pot is empty and Mc Cain is he face of defeat never to be seen again. The republicans will be back at the next eclection with the bush years forgotten a new face new ideas and a brown in the whitehouse.
michael , cahersiveen-adams town, madness
Mccain is unlikely to win for one simple reason: Democrats have been registering in huge numbers, while republicans lose interest. Bush has done nothing to uplift the country, only tell us how we will be at war permanently w/ terrorists. No attention to domestic issues by Repubs will cost mcain.
chris, Phx, USA
what YOU NEED to be asking yourselves is why are the polls showing dead even numbers between Obama and McCain if the Republican brand is so weak ! The Republican brand is fine . Its the NEO CONSERVATIVE brand that is weak for anyone educated . True conservatism ie Ron Paul is fine .
Destin, Nashville, US
The current rejection of the Republican party is neither an embrace of the Democratic party nor "progressive" ideologies. This can be seen by who has been beating the Republicans in special elections -- conservative Democrats. Republics should campaign and win or lose on principles.
Scott Maxwell, North Western, USA
The Reps had a wonderful opp. to gain worldwide leadership. It started with Afgh. and ended with Iraq. I have traveled Europe and never have I felt such vitriol directed at me for being an Amer.
If he can do the right thing with the Economy and bring back the U.S., Obama will restore our dignity.
Richard A., Seattle, Wa
Stan,
A right wing politician in the UK is still left of Democrat by U.S. standards. There is no party in the U.S. that has the power to instill European Socialism. I am a liberal/democrat by U.S. standards and after explaining my views to my UK friends i was more in line with their neo-fascist BNP.
Alex, London, England
What about the Democrats, especially the House leaders. Why do they get such a pass. Nancy Pelosi, and others, campaigned that they were going to solve the gas crisis among other things. Where is their grand plan to save America? The Democrats have done nothing.
David Dean, Coral Springs, USA
The republicans in America have positioned themselves, over the last generation, increasingly further right, and labled anyone even slightly to the left of them as 'liberal'. They no longer understand what moderation is, therefore, and couldn't find the middle (where the votes are) with both hands.
Michele R., Ann Arbor Michigan, USA
Andrew, you're misreading the tea leaves. What you are seeing is a market correction, not a meltdown. People of conscience are using market forces to effect change. It's no big deal. Granted, the GOP leadership should have managed their own better, but the rank and file will now do it for them.
Kate Shanahan, Nashville, USA
From an international point-of-view, I hope McCain wins because he seems to have the most ambitious and detailed plans to restore American prestige throughout the world. His League of Democracies, which would act in cases of UN failure to prevent genocide, has a lot of potential.
James, Newcastle, UK
McCain will be the next president - not because of race but political positioning. The Democratic Party has allowed the largest blunder to occur - it has allowed the left wing of the party to orchestrate an Obama victory without questioning the politics of the canidate. Obama will be hanged in Nov.
John Catsicas, Johannesburg, South Africa
Bush has sickened us. not just his immig. and katrina respnse. Mismanaged economy, tortured people in violation of the G.C., created more new enemies than at any time in the history of the world, he spied on and coerced his own people, destroyed the free press. he's america's worst shame.
betty, New York, USA
"McCameronism " is killing//has killed the Republican party in the USA.
Bob Hall, New York, United States
The REAL problem with the Republican party is revealed in Pawlenty's quote, "...have a message that REFLECTS [my emphasis] faces and voices of America."
Leaders inform the media, educate the public, and determine the political debate --"reflectors" abdicate leadership to the mass media, by default.
Ted Headlee, chattanooga, USA
Like the child raised by a liberal philosophy, who is taught to forever depend on someone else to take care of him.....so goes the current American public. Republicans bought into the same Democratic creed of spending to create a government underclass and a new elite status for themselves.
Rose, Richmond, USA
Limbaugh is absolutely correct. If the United States wants European socialism, then they should get it from the democrats, not the republicans. They should rebuild themselves as a true Jeffersonian alternative to Marx and give the nation a true alternative once socialism fails, which it will.
stan, Middletown IN, USA
The problem with Republicans is that most are liberals, and like liberals are racists, favoring black preferences/white discrimination and like liberals favor the socialist welfare state, which rewards greed and sloth by penalizing honest work.
JR Helton, Nashville, USA
No, Jimmy, we understand "green" global socialism all too well, it appeals to unenlightened hand-wringers like you & Sullivan who believe C02 is a pollutant. It's not. If only annoying progressives like Sullivan could be expelled from punditry when all their predictions prove false. McCain will lose
Andrew C., NJ, USA
Obama for President '08. Go, go, go.
Kevin, New York, USA
The problem with McCain going Green is that Republicans don't understand what that means! They'd most likely associate it with an illness of some sort!
McCain has being trying to send forth a populist message in the hope that this will work for him. Too late. Obama's already patented Hope & Change!
Jimmy C, Letchworth Garden City, UK