Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
The ritual of seeing your GP can be taxing: competing for limited daily appointments; sitting in hot surgeries swimming with germs; feeling guilty about taking up the doctor’s time . . .
Yet for many this experience may soon become a rare occurrence. The Government is encouraging us to see our local pharmacist more often to lessen the burden on doctors. In February, the first members of a new breed of prescribing pharmacists, who have taken on many of the roles of GPs, began to practise.
Ten million of us see a doctor or nurse every month, with 78 per cent of the population visiting the local surgery at least once a year. Nearly all of those visits lead to a prescription, and 73 per cent of us will be prescribed a medication every year, according to the NHS.
Over the past few years there has been a huge rise in the number of drugs and treatments available over the counter, without prescription, from our local chemists, from antibiotic eye drops to the morning-after pill. This year, in a pilot project, even the antiimpotence drug Viagra became available over the counter at chemists in Manchester. Now the Department of Health has stepped up a gear, with its scheme to give pharmacists more power to care for patients with chronic conditions such as diabetes and asthma. And this could mean a sharp cut in those millions of monthly GP visits.
New rules set in place last year have led to the creation of a special class of chemist, those who are qualified and licensed to be pharmacist independent prescribers (PIPs), who are able to offer any medicine for any medical condition within their competence, as long as it is not a controlled drug such as morphine. One of the first of these prescribers, Beth Hird, a specialist in asthma, has started to practise in Nottingham (see facing page). The Royal Pharmaceutical Society says that by the end of this year, there could be 1,100 PIPs countrywide.
These pharmacists will have to be commissioned by their local primary care trust, just like a GP, and then choose a specialist medical area; for example, diabetes. Many will be employed by the NHS, often based in local health centres, where they will provide a service alongside GPs and other health professionals. Independent sector pharmacists — high street chemists, for example — can also become PIPs. But, like the NHS pharmacists, they will have to go on a prescribing training course and they will be allowed to prescribe only in the areas in which they have been trained.
Some NHS pharmacists already run clinics for their local communities. For example, some assess chest infections to decide whether the GP needs to investigate further. But when the new system becomes more widespread, rather than a pharmacist saying to you “I think you need antibiotics for this, you’d better see a GP for a prescription”, a PIP in a clinic will be able to say: “Here is the antibiotic you need.”
People with conditions such as asthma, epilepsy or eczema may notice the changes first. Instead of being supervised by a doctor, they may be seen at a clinic run by a pharmacist, which could be at the pharmacy, GP surgery or even in a local hospital. And while initial diagnosis will usually come from a doctor, a PIP may sort out a treatment plan and revise it over time, assessing periodically how well a patient is responding to medication. This is something that pharmacists do not do at the moment and it has to be good news for anyone with a complicated drugs regimem, such as older people who may juggle statins to lower cholesterol levels, blood pressure pills, and tablets to soothe their stomachs from the effect of taking the other drugs.
Will there be a PIP near you? The Department of Health says that the number of PIPs will be determined not by government targets but by pharmacists and primary care trusts. In other words, local need and market forces will sort things out. But the department is keen to promote its new scheme. “Pharmacists are highly trained; we should use their skills,” a spokesman says.
David Pruce, a director of the Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain, which is backing the new plan, says: “We have five years’ training in medicines. Our expertise is second to none. And as medicines become more complicated, so do the interactions between different drugs. Pharmacists keep up to date in a way that no other health professionals can do, as that is the area they concentrate on.”
But some GPs are cautious. Pharmacists, they say, are not doctors. Without proper clinical training, is it appropriate for them to be making diagnoses and treatment plans, or handing out drugs after a quick consultation? Some are concerned that, although PIPs will have access to medical records, most high street pharmacists dispensing powerful medicines over the counter don’t. That means they can’t be certain what other medications a patient is taking. Some drugs can be dangerous if mixed: Viagra, for example, cannot be taken with nitrates (used to ease angina) as both cause blood pressure to fall and the cumulative effect might lead to collapse.
Dr Satya Sharma is a member of the British Medical Association’s clinical and prescribing subcommittee and has been a GP in Wolverhampton for more than 25 years. He says: “While I am delighted that pharmacists are seeing their role enhanced, there are grey areas that need addressing, and the prescription of drugs is one of them.
“GPs have advantages over pharmacists, aside from our training. After years in the surgery we often develop an instinct, which may help us when faced with a difficult diagnosis.”
He is concerned that some more seriously ill patients may be overlooked. Pruce is reassuring: “Will some patients slip through the net as doctors fear? No; we’re used to questioning them closely. One of my colleagues was approached by a man who wanted treatment for a wart. The pharmacist spotted that it wasn’t a wart: he was 90 per cent sure it was a melanoma or skin cancer. So he referred his patient to a doctor who was able to confirm the diagnosis. It’s no different from the way a GP refers a patient to a specialist.”
GPs and pharmacists are in agreement on one issue: communication between the two professions is vital if the system is to work.
“We are not frustrated GPs,” says Pruce. “We have expertise in medicine and can complement doctors. We are like different members of one team.”
What you can ask a chemist
High street pharmacists
Your local chemist can dispense an increasing range of medications to you over
the counter — statins, emergency contraception, antiinflammatory creams —
without prescription or a doctor’s referral.
Prescribing pharmacists
Since 2003 more and more NHS and high street pharmacists have trained as
“supplementary prescribers”, prescribing medicines already specified by a
doctor in a patient’s treatment plan. This helps people with long-term
conditions such as diabetes, heart disease and asthma. Ask your doctor for
details.
Specialist pharmacists
By the end of this year there could be more than 1,000 pharmacist independent
prescribers (PIPs) trained in specific areas of health and able to prescribe
medications and provide advice independently of doctors. They will be of
most use to people with long-term conditions. Ask your doctor for details.
Beth Hird is the first pharmacist licensed to prescribe drugs independently
Beth Hird, 29, is the first pharmacist independent prescriber (PIP) in the UK.
She runs an asthma clinic at St George’s Medical Practice, in Nottingham. The clinic operates once a week and was set up to review and manage patients with asthma, focusing on those who have recently become worse, who use a lot of inhalers and who need regular monitoring.
“Patients are generally invited in to see me, but they may be referred to me from their GP, or can come to the clinic themselves if they have seen me previously and are worried. I usually follow up patients until their condition is stable. If they require more complex support which falls outside my role as a PIP, I refer them back to their GP.
“I’ve developed a deep knowledge of asthma. I can educate patients about their asthma medications and show them how to manage their asthma effectively,” she says. “It’s a positive move for patients as there are more healthcare professionals for them to consult.”
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Pharmacists are currently the most under-used resource in the health service. In the ideal world doctors would diagnose and pharmacists would prescribe.
Very few people realise that pharmacists have a massive amount of knowledge regarding all areas of medication. Their training encompasses pharmacology, clinical therapeutics, microbiology, nutrition, biochemistry, and more. Pharmacists knowledge of the most appropriate drug to prescribe, how to prescribe it correctly and any interaction with other drugs or herbal medication is far superior to the average GP. Also, pharmacists do have diagnostical skills, are aware of their limits and know when it is appropriate to refer to a GP.
Nurses have been prescribing for years - due to a media friendly self-promoting body (RCN). However, pharmacists, although more skilled at this job have been left by the wayside for too long.
All in all - pharmacist prescribing would reduce medication errors and thus hospital admissions.
Nicola, London,
GPs are too "gung-ho" about prescribing powerful drugs. I prefer pharmacist advice when it comes to drugs, ever since a year ago when I was started on a certain medicine (doxazosin), and straight away started feeling terrible - dizzy, weak, nauseous, headached. After trying to put up with it for two days, I tried contacting the doctor, but was given an appointment in seven days time (great!). Out of exasperation I walked into one of my local pharmacies. He looked up the book, and showed me that the drug should have been started a lower dose and increased to the full dose gradually over a month to prevent side effects (clearly the GP couldn't be bothered).
The chemist contacted the doctor and I was started on a lower dose and felt much better. My blood pressure came down too, so I didn't need a higher dose. So I definatey support chemists (at least the ones I know) to have a more pro-active role in drug therapy, and protecting the public from gung-ho GP prescribing.
Russell, London, UK
I am a pharmacist and I welcome the introduction of PIPs as it will enable us to utilise our skills more effectively. It takes five years to qualify as a pharmacist - four years at university and a year in practice. Our training revolves around drugs; what effect drugs have, how drugs have their effects, how medicines are formulated, but we do cover some pathophysiology as well.
Pharmacists are not diagnosticians - that is the job of medics. It is a difficult job and on the whole they do it very well. However, any community pharmacist can differentiate between serious and minor complaints, and it is something we have to do on a daily basis. A pharmacist wishing to prescribe for asthmatics would have to do indepth training on asthma, which would also cover differential diagnosis. Although I have not done any specialist training in asthma, I am aware that shortness of breath may be due to asthma, COPD or heart failure, for example.
Steve, Kent,
Two days ago in my High St chemist an older lady,asking for pain relief, showed her osteo arthritic hand and was told it was wear and tear and sold a pain relief cream. It was unbelievable- those knobbly finger joints needed a NSAID or COX2 inhibitor from the GP!
It seemed cruel not to intervene so duly advised the lady to go to her GP for the right prescription to slow down her joint damage, which she agreed to do and thanked me.
This was an example of why chemists should not be prescribers.
v lock, aylesbury, UK
I don't think most GPs know enough about drugs to prescribe for people safely, its estimated that 15% of hospital admissions are because of avoidable drug side effects.
Pharmacists working closely alongside GPs (not pharmacists on their own) could seriously improve the nations health. I think rather than off-loading work onto Pharmacists, which is what is happening now, the government need to promote serious collaboration between the two professions in deciding which drugs a patient should be taking. That would be real progress.
Arjun, Ilford, Essex, UK
pharmacists do know lots about drugs, but they don't have the training to diagnose medical conditions. How can they prescribe antibiotics if they have had no training in microbiology? It is all very well altering asthma drugs, but they don't have the training to take a step back and ask themselves if this is just asthma or if the patient has another problem as well - knowing lots about one condition doesn't help to pick up another.
sarah, aberdeen,
Having personally had a previous misdiagnosis made about my health by a rushed GP, I would feel more comfortable consulting a pharmacist or nurse who had the time and attentiveness to listen to me than a rushed doctor who is trying to get me out of the consultation room as soon as possible with an ill-thought out prescription.
If the pharmacist or nurse felt something deeper was wrong that needed a second opinion, in my experience they wouldn't take a random guess, they would refer me. Like my local chemist told me to see the optician when he was unsure about some eye problem.
Priya, Plaistow, London, England
Prescribing a drug is the end of the process, not the whole process.
There is an growing assumption in the NHS that professionals skilled in one field will automatically be capable in other fields after limited retraining. This has more to do with saving money than providing safe and effective patient care.
Plumbers know a lot more than architects about pipes, boilers and the like but I know who I would want to design my house.
Julian Spinks, chatham, UK
Second class health care! Take time out to see your Doctor every year if you are well and under 50. For those over 50 twice yearly check ups are essential. Preventative medicine is mainly ignored in the National ? Health Service
(Sick Service). Ask you GP to start a "preventative medicine" programme for you. Better to know of any problems and deal with them early
Giles Wynne, Korat, Thailand
Will we soon be able to do without doctors at all? Conventional medicine is almost exclusively pharmaceutical-based, so it looks as though it's now 'over to the pharmacists'.
Mary, Stirling, Scotland
I'd much rather get drug advice from a pharmacist who understands drugs than a doctor who understands drug reps!
MIchael, Burton, UK
i think if you look at the number of hours the pharmacist spends studying pharmacology and therapeutics in university over a period of 4 years compared with the medics it is a massive difference. You would expect the pharmacist to know alot more especially with regards to side effects and mechanisms of actions of drugs. The good thing for medics is that these days they are encouraged to base practice on evidence often suported by NICE or the RCP for example. Medics pharmacology training usually begins as a junior house officer and will obvioulsy get better with experience and CPD development
Colin, liverpool, UK
I'd like to know which of the two professions has the greater knowledge of medicines being prescibed? Will pharmacists pay increase?
Julie, Leicester, UK