Diana Butterworth, a district nurse, is robustly sceptical of complementary
medicine, preferring to stick to mainstream treatments. So she did not
expect much from the kinesiologist (a practitioner of the alternative
therapy that studies body movement) whom her inlaws suggested she consult
about her back pain.
Butterworth arrived at the home of her husband’s parents near Andover,
Hampshire, three years ago “somewhat crooked” after spending three days
replanting her garden. “It must have been obvious to them as I got out of
the car that I was in pain,” recalls Butterworth, 36, who lives in
Bedfordshire with her husband William and three young sons. “I am fairly
sure that I injured my upper spine lifting a patient badly during my nursing
training, and my lower back stiffness could be to do with the fact that I’m
5ft 10in. Things have got worse since I turned 30. I began to have a sharp
pain that took my breath away when I made a sudden movement; for example,
when I was changing nappies, or unloading the dishwasher.”
Butterworth had visited her GP, who referred her to a physiotherapist. Six
sessions brought the pain under control, but within a year she was
stiffening up again. “The pain kept me awake at night and my back felt sore
as I put my feet on the ground in the morning.” She felt she had little to
lose when her inlaws suggested a visit to the kinesiologist Katharine
Graves, who lives near by.
Medical practitioners tend to regard it as among the wackier complementary
therapies and rigorous clinical trials have failed to prove that it works.
At the core of the therapy lies the concept of muscle testing. According to
kinesiologists, the behaviour of certain muscles can reveal where a
patient’s problems lie and give clues as to how he or she should be treated.
“Everybody who comes to see me says it is weird,” admits Graves. “And if
they don’t say it, I do, because it needs to be said. But I see it work
every day and sometimes the results seem miraculous. Just one session can be
enough to resolve problems that have gone on for years.”
Having established that Butterworth was suffering from back pain, Graves used
muscle testing to determine how best to treat it. Applying light pressure to
her patient’s outstretched right arm with one hand, she touched the thumb of
her other hand to each of her fingers in turn. When Graves’s thumb and
second finger met, Butterworth’s arm involuntarily dropped down, indicating
that her pain had an emotional component. “The amazing thing about
kinesiology is that it tells you with complete precision where the problem
is and what the body needs to treat it,” says Graves. “If you have had a bad
back for a while, there may well be worries and tensions going on that are
emotional.”
Allowing the energy to flow
With her patient lying on the couch fully clothed, Graves tested the 14
meridians (energy points) in Butterworth’s body, touching them to check
whether energy was flowing through them freely. Where she felt blockages,
she applied gentle pressure to known acupressure points. “Different muscles
relate to each meridian. With one hand, you hold the acupressure point on a
meridian that lacks energy and link it via the other hand to a meridian that
has energy: it’s rather like jump-starting a car. When the meridians come
into synchronicity, you know the job is done. There’s usually some little
sign such as a sigh, or a tummy rumble. When you check the body again, the
arm will not drop.”
Butterworth admits that she found the whole process extraordinary. “My arm
would suddenly drop as if I had no control over it. At the beginning of the
treatment I felt quite sharp pain when Katharine asked me to put my head in
certain positions. After she had worked her way around my body, the pain had
gone.
“Normally after a long bout of gardening I would expect my back to go into
spasm and be even more painful than usual, but seeing Katharine was like
taking antiinflammatories. I had no trouble at all afterwards and the
treatment was incredibly relaxing.”
Graves, who has been practising for ten years and is also an instructor, uses
craniosacral work, nutritional therapy and hypnotherapy as well as
acupressure. “No two people with the same problem are alike and it is
helpful to have a wide range of tools in your tool box,” she says. “Every
consultation is precisely tailored to the person with whom I am working.”
When Butterworth visited Graves again this summer after a recurrence of her
lower back stiffness, the kinesiologist used a different technique from her
treatment repertoire. While her patient held out her right arm, Graves
touched bottles containing Bach remedies: when Graves’s hand reached the
remedies rock rose and beech flower, Butterworth’s arm dropped. She used the
same method to identify how many drops were needed and repeated the process
with a list of nutritional supplements.
“My hand fell when she merely touched the names of three supplements on her
list,” says an incredulous Butterworth. “To be frank, I struggle with the
whole idea. This is not what I normally do and part of me cannot believe it
works. But both times I have seen Katharine I have felt much more
comfortable for some time afterwards. If it works – and it seems to for me –
I’d be a fool not to use it.”
Kinesiology facts
What is it? Based on principles of Chinese traditional medicine,
kinesiology was founded by a US chiropractor in the 1960s, to detect energy
imbalances in the body. Muscles are linked via nerves and, it claims, to
organs via energy pathways called meridians. Their response to tests can
point to problems.
Claims Good for all ages and afflictions. Eliminates physical,
chemical, emotional and spiritual stresses.
Cost A consultation with Katharine Graves takes about an hour and costs
between £50 and £70.
Contacts Katharine Graves, 0845 3379149; thekinesiologycentre.co.uk.
For other practitioners call the Kinesiology Federation, 08700 113545, kinesiologyfederation.org
. For practitioners to become members they must complete 150 hours of
training and 200 hours of clinical experience in two to three years.
WHAT’S THE EVIDENCE? DR TOBY MURCOTT
Can kinesiology treat back pain? There are no good-quality clinical
trials demonstrating its effectiveness. Until those trials are done, its
effectiveness will remain a matter of opinion rather than of hard clinical
evidence.
Did the acupressure do anything? A review published in 2006 found five
clinical trials that showed acupuncture was more effective than usual care
for back pain. However, another review last year of treatments for lower
back pain found no evidence that it eased the condition.
Could it be placebo? Yes. While there is evidence that belief in a
treatment may enhance the placebo effect, there are some suggestions that it
might be induced even in sceptics such as Diana Butterworth.
Is it safe? Kinesiology is a low-intervention technique and there are
no reports of direct harm. As is the case with many complementary therapies,
the greatest danger lies in practitioners encouraging patients to stop
taking other, tested, medication.
