Enter our Snapshots of Summer photography competition

“Catherine loves to mimic me: the other day I found her rubbing body lotion into her legs,” says her 47-year-old mother Tracey Holden, from Brentwood, Essex. “I’ve highlighted her hair before and she’ll quite often go out with a pair of my ‘chicken fillets’ under her top to give her a bit of cleavage. When she goes to the school disco, she’ll wear eye shadow, mascara and dress up in glittery clothes, and she has also signed up at Alphabet Kidz model agency. She’s a natural and she absolutely loves it.”
Tracey Holden’s daughter Catherine isn’t in her teens, as you might expect; she’s just 7, not yet out of Year 3. But a love of beauty products inherited from her mother has propelled her from the wide-eyed innocence of childhood into a world of make-up and glitz more commonly inhabited by girls three times her age.
“I come from a long line of women who love make-up,” says Tracey. “I have always made sure that my appearance was of a high standard and my two girls have followed me. I believe that if a child is grounded, dabbling with a bit of make-up or having her hair highlighted isn’t the crime of the century. Appearance is very important to self-esteem. So why not make the best of yourself?”
Kids can choose their own identity
A desire to emulate a mother’s grooming ritual is nothing new, but is it just harmless mimicking or are we exposing our children to undesirable attention? On the positive side, the journey into tweenhood – the transitional stage between girlhood and adolescence – can be seen as a natural part of growing up. With it comes peer approval, a feeling of belonging, a chance to measure up to older friends and siblings. After a lifetime of being dressed by parents, they are finally allowed to mould their own identity and there are no end of tween role models, from Kylie and Britney and Pop Idol stars to the fairytale princess in films such as Enchanted, Disney’s eagerly awaited tween offering that hits the big screen on December 14.
“There has been a big resurgence in the US of princess and girlie icons,” says Jean Ford, the co-founder of Benefit cosmetics. “The idea of transforming into your favourite storybook or movie character is very popular with tweens.”
Fatima Bholah, the beauty editor of Mizz and Bliss teen magazines, says: “Young girls have always been interested in make-up. It’s natural for a young girl to want to play with make-up on themselves and their friends. The emphasis is not vanity at this age: it is about experimenting and dressing up.”
But, says Karen Sullivan, the author of You Want to Do What?(Collins, £9.99), a manual for parents of teenagers, there is a darker side to a preoccupation with self-image and a desire to look good in front of your peers. “Children may acquire the trappings of maturity, but their judgment and development are far behind. It is not harmless fun to encourage children to seek physical perfection through makeover parties, hair removal and choosing highly sexualised clothing. It leaves them vulnerable to feelings of inadequacy when they fail to match up to their role models and, at a time when body image is being established, this can have profound implications.
“Eating disorders and extreme dieting are increasingly common in youngsters,” Sullivan says, “as are early sexual encounters and alcohol abuse. It goes without saying that if a child is treated and dressed like an adult, they will naturally experiment with other aspects of their lifestyle. It also creates a ‘what next?’ mentality. And what is next? Breast implants at 16? Cosmetic surgery? A lifetime of seaching for elusive perfection.”
Baby groomers are a lucrative market
However, the glittery pound is stronger than ever. Last year a Euromonitor International report entitled Tweens – A Force to be Reckoned With: Changing Consumption Habits of 8 to 12-Year-Olds estimated tween spending worldwide at $170 billion (£82 billion). Now able to get their hands on more money than ever before, through allowances and gifts, young girls want products that cultivate a sophisticated, adult self-image. “Agelessness is now a major social trend,” claims Nica Lewis, of the market analyst Mintel. “While grandparents are acting and looking younger than ever before, kids are doing the opposite – getting older younger. They have more responsibility thrust on them at a younger age and are increasingly making their own purchasing decisions.”
Keen to claim their slice of this lucrative market, the beauty industry has come up with a growing number of products to satisfy the new generation of baby groomers. Recently the US company Nair launched Nair Pretty, a hair-removal product aimed at 10 to 15-year-olds, after focus groups revealed to the company’s research directors that tweens were regularly treating themselves to “hair-removal slumber parties”.
In addition, L’Oréal Paris Kids now has its own shampoos; Barry M Cosmetics Nail Paints and Dazzle Dusts were originally created for a young market; and Superdrug, the store for all things sparkly, has become a huge draw for tweens.
Should eight-year-old girls go to spas?
A growing number of tweens are dipping their manicured toes in treatments at pampering haunts such as spas salons and nail bars. Spa Finder, a worldwide online spa resource, recently reported the number of requests from consumers for tween services such as manicures has tripled in the past year. Its 2008 directory will, for the first time, list the minimum age for spa-goers at each spa, the youngest being 8.
Hannah Webley-Smith, the co-director of the Ritual Rooms in London, whose Little Miss treatments include an Anne Semonin “Face Wash” (a mini cleanse, tone and moisturise), from £42, and a Little Miss “Petit Mani”, from £15, believes that you’re never too young to start grooming. “It’s good to get into beauty rituals at an early age; it teaches girls to look after themselves,” she says. “Our clients are definitely sophisticated for their age, in their dress sense and accessories. Parents tend to pay for their treatments, and we sometimes get five or six bookings in a week. We saw a definite growth period over the summer.”
Party organisers across the country are also reporting increased requests from parents to treat their tween daughters and friends to make-up parties as part of their birthday celebrations. Pamper parties – such as can be found at www.gorgeousgirlsparty.com – even invite girls as young as 4 to experiment with temporary hair extensions, make-up and nail art. The two-hour party includes mini makeovers for all the guests, games and a gift for the birthday girl. So much for pass the parcel.
While some mothers are only too happy to see their children transformed into mini adults, others are less comfortable with the idea. Lesley Chivers, the PR manager at the cosmetics company Bourjois, wants her daughter Nicole, 8, to hang on to her childhood as long as possible.
“Since the age of 5, Nicole’s been pleading, ‘Can I have my ears pierced?’ My husband and I always say the same thing: ‘No, not this year’. I think she should wait till she’s 12 or 13. And rather than spend time together at a salon, I’d prefer to bond with her in other ways; we’ll go clothes shopping or take the dog for a walk.”
For Alma van Vuuren, 43, it is her 11-year-old daughter who finds the whole idea of tween cosmetics a turn-off. “Ronelle would much rather spend time painting pottery than painting her face. She has often said to me that her friends don’t talk about anything other than make-up and boys, and she finds that annoying.”
So why are some mums happy to let their daughters indulge in adult grooming while others put their foot down? Sue Palmer, an educational expert and the author of the best-selling parenting handbook Detoxing Childhood (Orion, £9.99), says: “It depends on their background and self-confidence, and the extent to which they’re able to resist marketing pressures.”
Karen Sullivan says: “We can’t remove the media from children’s lives completely, but we parents can balance its impact by teaching moral values, encouraging children to value personality, personal achievement and positive virtues over an all-consuming interest in looks.
“We can encourage children to wait until the appropriate time for various freedoms and rites of passage, such as getting ears pierced, or wearing make-up and suggestive clothing. It is not a parent’s role to play best friend, but to guide and nurture, and, most importantly, to protect their children.”
Should you let a six-year-old wear make-up? Have your say at
timesonline.co.uk/makeuponchildren
What can parents do?
Talk to other parents and express worries about kids dressing as mini adults. You’ll find that many parents share your feelings, and together you can shift the balance.
It’s unfair to exclude your child from parties but you can express disapproval. Negotiate a compromise. Say you’re happy for her to go to the makeover party but you won’t agree to anything permanent or invasive – no piercings, no waxing and no hair colour.
Start a trend for different, healthier activities, such as pottery painting, bowling, trips to the cinema, theatre or local football match. Hold make-your-own music video parties with the family video camera. These may seem old-fashioned, but they are suitable and fun for tweens.
Watch your behaviour. Tweens learn a great deal about the world through parents. If you’re preoccupied with dieting, beauty treatments and sexy clothes, you can be sure that your child will follow suit.
Make sure your child develops a healthy self-image by praising effort, personality, achievements, and sense of humour rather than focusing on looks.
KAREN SULLIVAN, the author of You Want to Do What? (HarperCollins, £9.99)
Painting by numbers
63% of 7 to 11-year-olds wear lipstick, more than two in five wear eye shadow or eyeliner, and almost one in four wears mascara
75% of 11 to 14-year-olds wear eye shadow, and a similar proportion wear mascara
80% of 11 to 14-year-olds wear lip gloss or lipstick
50% of 11 to 14-year-olds wear blusher, with 14 per cent using it at least once a day
58% of girls wear perfume by the age of 14
Source: 2004 Mintel report
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I'm 16 I just thought I'd add a presumably younger perspective on it. I agree that it is ridiculous that such young kids are going to beauty spars I can't afford to go them now even what a waste of money on something that they don't need. That'll just make them spoilt and unappreciative of money. Experimenting with make-up is fine my mum used to give m some of her spare make-up when I was ten i experiemented with it a little then got bored of it. I think a little experimentation with make-up is good practice and just general fun I kinda think though that when kids are 11 their parents should maybe give them a little make-up or fashion advice or beauty care or w/e
because it's very difficult to fit into highschool when you're that young you need to make a good impression with your fellow pupils. I remember my mum wudn't let me shave my legs which did need shaving tbh and tht caused more bother for me than i needed. As for teenagers I agree we need more advice on make-up XD
Roxanne, Stoke-on-trent, UK
Insanity to think that girls cannot be redirected towards more appropriate fun. Girls are driven by a desire to have fun, create and be with friends. The idea that a girl if left to her own devices (and not improperly influenced) would do any of this stuff is rubbish!
David Cote, Chatham, USA, NJ
Hair removal slumber parties?!
Has the world gone quite mad? What hair could an eight year old possibly have to remove?
Ye gods! I despair for this generation, especially as their parents seem to be less keen on being parents than of being overgrown teenagers themselves. Thank God my daughter has grown up and was allowed to do so, I might add, at her own pace.
A. Watson, London,
I'm appalled by the mother who allows her daughter of seven to wear chicken fillets to "give her a bit of cleavage". Why on earth does a child need to have cleavage? It makes me feel sick to see these mothers reliving their youth vicariously through their daughters.
Kath, Abergavenny,
Tracey Holden is under the mistaken belief that self-esteem can be procured through lipstick. It's not; self-value, self-worth and self-esteem come from within. What sort of message is she sending her daughter? Silly question, that's clear to see!
Alexandra, Cologne, Germany
There are two different issues going on here. Little girls like to play with makeup as do some little boys, one of my sons when he was very little would ask for a dab of lipstick when ever I put mine on. Completely harmless and nothing to make an issue of at all. The trouble starts when common sense and responsible parenting goes out of the window. By allowing young children to wear a full face of makeup every day and encourageing them to indulge in adult beauty regimes is irresponsible. Give children back their childhood and stop trying to make them into mini adults.
When teenagers start to experiment with makeup, teach them to highlight and not mask. The amount of orange faces is frightening. I can't believe the amount of parents who let their daughters out of the door looking like that, it is cruel as they look ridiculous and only get into trouble at school.
Tania, Runcorn, UK