Julia Neuberger
Enter our Snapshots of Summer photography competition
Look around you, there are notices everywhere: “Be careful: keep your eye on your possessions”, “Swim at your own risk — no lifeguard on duty”. We are told by government to be alert to the risk of terrorists. And we are watched by CCTV wherever we go. But all this advice to be watchful makes us fearful. It makes us shrink into ourselves. We become unkind, unconcerned for others, and our children become terrified of the outside world.
These days, you have to have a Criminal Records Bureau check before you volunteer to work with anyone described as vulnerable — children, anyone over 65, and a whole lot of others besides. That makes many young men, especially, nervous about volunteering at all, and others deeply irritated that they are being asked for a CRB check to work, say, in hospital radio.
If a young man has a criminal record, but now wants to help others who are younger still — just getting into trouble with the police and at risk of worse — he has to be incredibly determined not to be put off by the marathon of bureaucracy.
Hospital staff are often told not to put an arm round patients to comfort them lest it be viewed as assault. So it tends to be the porters and care assistants who give a bit of comfort, while the nurses only touch the patients when they have to carry out some kind of intervention. Many people, especially older people, don’t want too many interventions. What they want is human contact, a bit of tender loving care.
We are all so terrified of child sexual abuse that we have outlawed taking photographs of children at nursery school without parental consent. And adults are terrified that their motives will be suspected if they talk to a child or, even worse, hug one. So, a few years ago, when Clive Peachy, a bricklayer, saw two-year-old Abigail Rae walking down the road after she had escaped from her nursery school in Warwickshire, he did not stop and help her because he thought people would think he was trying to abduct her. The result? She drowned in a pond.
Young male volunteers in primary schools describe feeling like pariahs, viewed with suspicion by many staff — when all they are doing is trying to help. And children want comfort if they fall over in the playground, yet teachers have been told never to touch the children in their care. So you get 12-year-olds with broken legs crying for their mothers, with staff unable to give them a hug, and five-year-olds putting sunscreen on each other because the teachers have been instructed not to touch them. The mess that ensues, and the visits to hospital because cream gets in their eyes, would be funny were it not so ridiculous. Equally absurd are the letters informing parents that children should not bring home-made birthday cakes into school in case of food poisoning — a position that results in children being less likely to share.
So what is all this about? First, there is a real fear of being sued, far greater than the actual numbers of cases would warrant. Second, there is a fear of what others might think. We have begun to internalise the messages that people might think we are abusers when we are not. Third, we are fearful of our children being injured, being killed, being abducted. Yet, in terms of ordinary accidents happening to children, the numbers have gone down dramatically rather than up over the last 30 years.
Nevertheless, our children are frightened to go outside because, as the think-tank Demos and the Green Alliance demonstrated a few years ago, they fear the outside world. They think the streets are full of terrorists, murderers and child-abductors. Worse, they think they know what they look like. They are white, male, middle-aged, wear horrible clothes and have a funny look in their eyes.
But children would not feel like this if adults did not encourage them. It is adult fear, stoked by government and insurers, by risk assessors and hospital and school managers. If we aren’t careful, the next generation will consist entirely of wimps. They will go off on adventure holidays abroad, but they will not walk down the street or get on the Tube alone for fear of attackers. The net result will be not only a lack of life skills, but overwhelming fear: of predators, of accidents, of life itself.
Meanwhile, the sexual predators will carry on just as before — largely in the family — because no system of checks will root them out completely. And we will have created a whole generation of unhappy people. We need to be sensible, not risk-averse; we need to look out to see where we can help others. And, sometimes, we may even need to touch them.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the collective power of smart thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Flip MinoHD Camcorder
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
42,945
2008
71,450
Car Insurance
Not Specified
MI6
UK-based
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Save up to £1,000 per couple with Elite Vacations at the five-star Constance Lemuria Resort
and do the British Isles this Summer.
Save up to 60% with Oxford Hotels and Inns
Try our inspiring luxury holidays to the Indian Subcontinent and South East Asia.
Great offers available
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
...and this is why I do not want to have a child in this country, but rather elsewhere, where children might still have a normal childhood, and affection is not an offence to anybody... Lack of affection in childhood leads to psychological disorders later in life....Thank you for the article.
laura g., calcot, UK
I am teaching in China to kids aged from 6-10, physical contact between teachers and pupils here is very much encouraged and I must say it greatly pleases me to see the little ones running up to me for a hug. it saddens me to think kids and teachers back home are denied this due to hysteria!
Helen, 21, Wuhan, China
At a useful inset we were all given Post-it stickers; one person stood with her back to the group, and we had to put a sticker where we thought it was OK to touch: mostly, shoulders, upper arms etc. Why not? We all need a pat on the back, or some TLC
Veronica, Gloucester, UK
Irish expat, I've been a teacher of children here 20 years. If I, as a male, didn't touch the children, the parents would wonder what was my problem. What is the UK's problem that it has gone bizarre over this "touch" hysteria? It is wrong. Just look at your statistics.
Tom McGuire, Castellon, Spain
This article highlights an important problem which is rarely discussed. I am working in junior high schools in Japan and the sitution is far different here. Teachers and students are not afraid to touch one another. The result: Delightful children and a school atmosphere with a family-like feel.
Richard, Ishikawa Prefecture, Japan/England
It's not quite as ridiculous in Canada, but it's certainly getting there. Let's hope this is a phase and the next generation of parents realize how ridiculous it is. I'll be having kids in a few years and I will NOT be teaching them to be afraid of everything!
Greg, Calgary, Canada
I helped out in my daughter's class several times. The teacher could not have been less gracious, unwelcoming and hostile. There were a couple of other helpers - a mother and a grandmother - who were very welcoming and said how pleased they were to see a male helper for a change. Never again.
Martin, Hove, Uk
"They think the streets are full of terrorists, murderers and child-abductors. .. They are white, male, middle-aged, wear horrible clothes and have a funny look in their eyes."
I thought they'd been told all terrorists were Muslim and child-abductors were swarthy egg-men who left no physical trace..
JM, Koeln,
I was at a 'soft play' centre with my 3 year old son a few weeks ago. At the top of the large climbing area there was a girl of about 3 in floods of tears wanting her mummy - I took her and my son straight down the exit slide, but on the way down thought "I hope her parents don't see me". Tragic.
Karl, Wirral,
Unfortunately, all it takes is one well publicised child abduction, abuse and muder to create paranoia. It's pointless trying to allay fears with statistics because every incident is one too many!! The real enemy is the soul-less state that disempowers and controls its people through fear.
DavidP, Surrey, UK
As a trainee lawyer I volunteerd to work in a primary school for a day. One of the children said I touched and hit him. I was so overwhlemed I vomitted. My life flashed before my eyes - literally. The headmaster told me "oh, he always says that, don't worry". The most frightening moment of my life.
PSF, London, UK
i carry on just as i always have, i won't be beaten by Labour propaganda. if i saw a lone child wondering around i'd stop and speak to them. i hold my nieces' hands when i take them out. if anyone has a problem with that it's their problem. i'm not a paedo and i won't be treated as one
mike, sheffield,
The irony is that the vast majority of molestation occurs within families, so the keeping of strangers away is missing the point, or at least most of it. I also think of the subtle effects that happen when all men are treated as possible pedophiles has on the consciousness of kids.
Michael , Miami Beach, USA
Removing all risk does not keep children safe; it simply prevents them from being able to assess risk.
Nothing makes me more angry than schools' constant Stranger Danger teaching - it scares kids to death and OF THE WRONG PEOPLE. I take the opposite approach and teach my children to think.
Morag, Maidstone,
I think this isn't so common in other countries. I used to hug my grade 2 teacher in Canada and there was nothing strange about it. She used to hug every student in class, she was just a very warm friendly person. I read this article and I am truly baffled by it. Do places really exist like this?
Steve, Calgary, Canada
there is a touch of urban myth about this piece; nothing at all positive and despite my concerns about the way British society is going I still see evidence of old fashioned care. And maybe those of us who feel strongly must keep fighting rather than simply lamenting.
JR, Llandeilo,
I used to work with youth all the time, until a camping trip when one of kids parents were not home when we came back. ( they had gone to the beach!). I realized I could lose everything I owned own. Never again. I am not being a baby sitter for irresponsible or uncaring parents. Very sad .
Tom, asheville nc, usa
In my late 40's (in UK) when training to be a cricket coach I was warned off for "comforting" a boy who had been hit by a ball........ Due to this, the CRB and similar, I have never used my qualification to coach. There are many like me I am sure - cricket, football, Sunday School, Scouts.....
Steve, Kigali, Rwanda
Heck, I'm a *woman* who lives in the US and I'm terrified to be anywhere near other people's children, let alone speak to them and God forbid touch them, lest I be hauled away to jail and be a social pariah for the rest of my life for something that somebody else only thought I did.
Meg, Rome, USA
didn't that one smart guy say... "we having nothing to fear, but fear itself"
sam , winder, GA, USA
Ben makes a good point about male role models. It's reached the point where a dad can't hold his child's hand in public. Men are moved if they find themselves sitting next to an unrelated child on a plane. No wonder there are now hardly any male primary teachers. Demonizing men is ruining sociey.
DMC, Tokyo, Japan
Can't you all see this was the goal? The government both UK and US work with the media to poison our brains with fear where we are too crippled to function as a society should. This article spoke to me, Im 22 male and live in the US. I find myself uncomfortable just being around kids.
Brian, Parkersburg, US
I used to be a substitute teacher. I was randomely assigned to classes. You should have seen the looks I got when I was assigned to teach kindergarten gym for the day. With all the stares I felt like a criminal. I wanted to scream I didn't ask for this , I'm not some pedo.
Joe, Jeffersonville, USA
It's not the "world", but the United States. Folks in Asia, Europe, and elsewhere still comfort children and hold them, even if they're not the parents. We're the ones with the problems. I see folks holding and caring for kids all the time where I live here in Michigan. I am not afraid.
chub, Clinton Township, USA
True but sometimes we cant blame people when all they hear about is senseless crimes. Like it or not, we still have to admit that the media is just carrying on its task: conveying the truth. Horrible things do happen and who knows the consequences may be immeasurable if we turn a blind eye.
amanda, singapore,
Britain may be stupid in this. But fortunately the rest of Europe is quite sensible about it. Normal human contact is not taboo, and if people take risks and occasionally get hurt , tough luck.
tom, chorley,
We wonder why our children are forming gangs etc. They are desperate for male role models and they find them not in schools or volunteer clubs, but on the streets. There are no CRB checks for these people.
Ben, Huddersfield, Japan,
Great piece...I feel that the problem stems from people not being media literate...seeing a report of something horrible and then assuming that this happens everywhere. Oh and watching the news every night doesn't help...b/c if you hear something enough, you will begin to believe it.
Evan, Santa Barbara, USA
:) I am so happy about this article. I feel it is so true and there is too much fear in the world.
Roy Boden, Davis, United States
I agree that "no touch" has gone too far. Our church had a "seminar" for Sunday school teachers and assistants. Assistants? Right, because no one should be alone with a child! What if a toddler has to go to the toilet? One suggestion was that the teacher take another child in also!
Dorian Borsella, Fallston, Md., USA
I'm 46. I was never hugged by a teacher or touched by anyone that I can remember ( apart from being caned by my art teacher). Is it just that am between the age-group that was (apparently) constantly being hugged, and the age-group that was denied this pleasure (due to the modern world, etc.) ?
beech, hornsea,
Didn't one of the phone companies abandon the slogan "Reach out and touch someone." because they were concerned about law suits if anyone misunderstood or took the slogan too far?
Law suits have become a way of life and it's a shame. It's the 98% or attorneys that give the rest a bad name.
Rowena, Las Vegas, US
This all stems from a single guiding principle: that safety is always paramount. In fact it isn't; exposure to risk is essential for children to develop into adults who can take care of themselves and others.
Adam, London, UK
TRUE!
I live in East Eur.{Slovakia)where people do not have the hang-ups about touching.Children still play outdoors & life is not regulated to the most ridiculous degree.In Britain, nowadays,I fear, children are being raised unnaturally-the UK needs again discipline& to learn from other cultures.
Conrad Riepl, Banska Bystrica, Slovkia
One of my most memorable moments is when my RE teacher gave me a great big long hug in the classroom. We were on our own - and I was very upset. I was 15 and she was in her 50's. Nothing else happened. I was respected and felt loved & comforted. She was a REAL teacher.
Barry Johnston, Sheffield, United Kingdom
You do realise what drives this? NOT the feministas, it's the bloody lawyers again...
Aided and abetted by the politicians - who pass ridiculous laws at the whinge of a left wing liberal.
Could we please turn off the hairsplitting and nanny-dom, and turn back on common sense and genuine compassion
Chris, St Leonards-on-sea, UK
People feel obliged to demand CRB checks even when they are totally inappropriate because they fear the consequences of not doing so. This is litigation panic. It significantly cripples volunteer-led activities. In the end, refusing to accept and manage risk impoverishes us all.
richard, horley, UK
Touch is all about trust. People are moving farther and farther away from the social interaction that brings about trust. The more time we spend away from people, the more we start to fear and misunderstand them, making it ever harder to socialize properly. Technology is a two-edged sword...
Don, Reno,
This has to change. This is what happens when you let lawyers run our institutions. As I told many lawyers before, if we allow them to tell us how to run our business, none us would be do business. Giving basic human care... that's exactly where we need them the least.
Deline, Washington DC, USA
I live in the US, and it seems to me that things aren't quite as bad here as described in this article, but I can see things heading that way. I think this paranoia is getting a bit out of hand when you can't hug someone.
Eric, Bend, Oregon, USA
The net result of the so-called "Women's movement" that resurfaced in the 1990s just turned women into guaranteed victims. Like whites have white guilt, now men have male guilt and are terrified of questioning the authenticity of the claims that are made. This article missed the boat by about 15yr
Mark, New York,
I'm from Texas, and I know that my teachers in elementary school never had a problem giving me a hug or anything of that nature, although some of the symptoms the author described are applicable in the U.S. as well. Perhaps this problem is worse in the U.K.?
David, Austin, TX., US
That is so deep rooted in the American and British culture that I don't think it is going away for a long time.
Individualism has its disadvantages and that is one, a cocktail of isolation, fear and superficiality.
Daniel, Madrid, Spain