Maurice Chittenden
Enter our Snapshots of Summer photography competition
IT WAS intended to be the symbolic gesture at a global series of rock concerts next month to alert people to climate change. Al Gore, the former US presidential candidate turned climate doomsayer, had wanted a massive switch-off of lights by television audiences, but the National Grid has vetoed the idea.
The inconvenient truth, it says, is that the power surge when people switched their lights back on could cause disruptions in supply and even endanger hospital patients on life support machines.
Live Earth will be a series of concerts, modelled on Live Aid and and Live 8, aimed at raising awareness about the threat from global warming.
As many as 12 concerts across seven continents featuring the likes of Madonna and Genesis and 100 other acts are planned over 24 hours, including one at a research station in Antarctica.
The organisers have so far struggled to find a clear-cut way of conveying their main message. Even rock performers have criticised the concept.
Roger Daltrey, of the Who, said another concert would simply waste fuel; Bob Geldof, who helped to organise Live Aid and Live 8, said people were already aware of the greenhouse effect; while Matt Bellamy, front man of the rock band Muse, labelled it “private jets for climate change”.
The switch-off was conceived as an emblematic act in the same way that Will Smith, the actor, coordinated people across the world to click their fingers every three seconds during the Live 8 concerts to convey that in Africa another child had died.
It was meant to create a moment that would resonate round the world and provide a counterpoint to the old fad for holding carbon-emitting cigarette lighters aloft at concerts.
It would also have given Britain its biggest blackout since the blitz and the miners’ strikes of the 1970s – and encapsulated the message of the urgency to save energy.
However, it has had to be shelved after the keepers of Britain’s power supply said no. “We are in favour of sustained energy efficiency as opposed to people just doing it very suddenly as a stunt,” said a spokesman for the National Grid.
“The organisers of Live Earth planned to do this very symbolic act but we had concerns because it was impossible for us to forecast what would happen.”
John Gaydon, producer of the British concert at the new Wembley stadium, said: “The National Grid warned us that it would put too much pressure on the power supply and would be potentially dangerous for hospitals.”
Gore has admitted that the concerts will consume a vast amount of electricity. To combat criticism of their own damaging effect on the environment, the organisers will pay at least £1m in carbon credits and supply acts with hybrid cars, partly run on electricity, to ferry stars to venues as well as fuel-efficient Smart cars to run around backstage.
They also claim that the power for the shows will come from green suppliers and biofuels. Food and drink sellers will use biodegradable plastics and there will be waste recycling systems.
The event at Wembley on July 7 will be headlined by Madonna, who green campaigners say used 440 tons of CO2 in four months on her Confessions tour last year. Artists from America lined up for the stadium include the Black Eyed Peas, Red Hot Chili Peppers and John Legend, a singer who has been criticised for making advertisements for 4x4 vehicles.
A proposal for Gore to appear at concerts in Britain and America on the same day – something that Phil Collins, the Genesis drummer and singer, was able to do at the original Live Aid in 1985 courtesy of Concorde – has been dropped because of the anger that the “gas-guzzling” flight would provoke among environmentalists.
The National Grid intervention puts in doubt whether Gore, whose surprise hit film An Inconvenient Truth warned of the imminent dangers of global warming, will appear in London at all. A spokesman for his office said: “We are not entirely sure where he is going to be. It would have been logical for him to have been in London but now he is probably going to be in New York at some point.”
The New York show will include British stars such as the Police and Roger Waters. A global TV audience of two billion is expected to watch the events. There will also be concerts in Brazil, China, Japan, South Africa, Australia and Turkey.
Janet Wood, of Utility Week, the industry’s trade journal, said: “Power companies spend a lot of time predicting when they are going to have high demands.
“They can cope with sudden surges when they know they are going to happen such as at the end of a television programme, but they like to know exactly when they are going to happen.
“The organisers of the concerts might decide to buy from green suppliers but they have no way of knowing how the electrons they use are generated.”
The biggest recorded power drop in Britain was 2,700 megawatts during the three-minute silence for the victims of the September 11, 2001 attacks. The biggest surge was 3,000 megawatts after the solar eclipse in 1999.
Deprived of their concept of creating a mass blackout, the Live Earth organisers will rely instead on the spoof rock band Spinal Tap to help the public see the light on global warming.
The band, whose guitarist Nigel Tufnel notoriously insisted on turning his speakers beyond the maximum 10 to 11, will be joined on stage by Ricky Gervais, the comedian.
Rob Reiner, director of the film which launched Spinal Tap in 1984, said that in the routine for Live Earth the band initially struggles to grasp the concept of climate change. “Nigel thought it was because he was wearing too much clothing – and that if he just took his jacket off it would be cooler,” Reiner said.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the collective power of smart thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Flip MinoHD Camcorder
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
42,945
2008
71,450
Car Insurance
Not Specified
MI6
UK-based
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Save up to £1,000 per couple with Elite Vacations at the five-star Constance Lemuria Resort
and do the British Isles this Summer.
Save up to 60% with Oxford Hotels and Inns
Try our inspiring luxury holidays to the Indian Subcontinent and South East Asia.
Great offers available
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Is it likely to cause any more of a problem than other surges in demand which the grid needs to cope with?
Perhaps the National Grid are more worried about people getting into the habit of saving energy and reducing demand. Energy saving is the most effective way to protect the environment and if this event had a lasting legacy it would be worthwhile - a one-off token gesture would not.
Pete, Ipswich, UK
This is a clear hijacking of environmentalism by globalists. I consider it a brilliant move that turns those who were normally anti-globalism into pro-globalists.
If the greens ever wondered how neo-cons hijacked christian fundamentalism... they are now learning first hand.
Looking at the proposed solutions to the problem instantly reveals the intent of the movement. Profit and control.
Davin, Portland, USA
Abuse of our planet is irrelevant unless each of us recognise we are the 'planet'. All the garbage spouted from this or that scientist, politician, media mogul is worth zero without the recognition that the only thing we have to leave to those who come after us is apprehension.
Phia , Scaynes Hill, U.K.
1) Al Gore had an appointment with the environmental editor of the most popular Danish newspaper, but when he learned that the more knowledgeable environmentalist Bjorn Lomborg would also attend the meeting, he cancelled his appointment.
In the 1950's and 1960's, thousands of people in London died each year from the air pollution. In order to stop this, the heights of chimneys were raised . This angered Gore, since it led to some minor air pollution reaching Sweden. He didn't care about Londoners dying, he didn't want Sweden to have minor pollution.
Roger Bell, Ashton, MD
Why don't they all ride around on Zipee-bikes? Hybrid cars still use fossil
fuels...
Steve Stoke, reading, UK
I think it's great... for Al Gore.
One man who didn't succeed to become the most powerful politician in the world, by being democratically elected into office, has now assumed power on a planetary scale without a vote being cast.
He decides what the perfect global temperature should be... not too hot, not too cold but juuuuust right. I'm not sure when that point was in the last x billion years of earth's constantly (and naturally) changing global temperature but Al Gore is convinced that it's going in the wrong direction, despite the fact that life on earth has thrived for hundreds of millions of years in a constantly varying climate, at times cooler and warmer than today. Species have evolved and become extinct, time and again.
What exactly is the perfect temperature for the planet? Should man strive (despite what nature does itself) to maintain that temperature? What happens when nature say 'tomorrow's going to be 2 degrees colder and we'll have a new ice-age'? We fight it?
Ad, Nottingham, UK
Gore spends $30k per annum on fuel at his mansion. 'Nuff Sed.
Nobby Clark, London,
Didier in Brussels,
I resent that you are condemning the anti-all. You are pre-judging them and missing the point that if they are right about global warming then it is indeed a beautiful thing they are doing. You should stop judging people who judge. It isn't nice, I'm sorry. I'm afraid I have just judged you for judging the anti-all who seem to judge eveyone. I retract this statement, I hope you don't judge me harshly for judging you for judging the anti-all who judge eveyone.
I'm going to Al Gore's website so I can offsett all carbon I just created by perspiring while writing this. "Friends don't let friends cut their hair" Please stop choking our rivers and oceans with human hair. Don't get a haircut.
Bryan theterrible, Los Angeles,
When I was in high school, during the 70s, the so-called experts were predicting another ice age and the catch phrase for that time period was "global cooling".
One thing that you've got to ask yourself about this so-called "global warming" theory and those that support it is who stands to profit from it.
Fred Stueve, Burns, Wyoming
people love to criticize - the truth is that while yes, many people in the world are already aware of the climate crisis, there are many more who are not aware of how serious this actually is. the massive number of people who will tune in to watch their favorite artists and come away with a new understanding and willingness to change certain destructive activities will more than make up for the fuel used to transport some of the artists to the shows.
and re. the criticism of al gore consulting on environmental issues - well, the fact is that people get paid every day for the work they do. i personally do not know what money he does or does not make. that being said, i would much rather get behind the guy who is using his creativity, passion and intelligence to help solve one of the most serious threats to human existance on this planet. he has devoted his life to helping to find a solution....why should he be chastized for earning a living, if indeed that is the case?
terra , london, england
The temperature of Mars is increasing in line with the Earth's because of the way the martians live.
Al Gore should be sent to Mars to tell the martians how irresponsible their lifestyle is.An inconvenient trip for Al but also
a chance to become the saviour of two planets.(And if the martians
don´t have a planetary computer network yet ,Al can invent it for them as he has claimed to have done here on Earth.)
Mauri Ahlaja, Turku, Finland
Al Gore - The lights are on, but there's nobody home
p.s. Where can I buy my indulgences from Mr Gore to ensure my place in carbon free heaven?
john smith, manchester, uk
B J Deller from Marbella in Spain, Sam Young in Paris France, and all the others who dispute the effects of human activity on the changes to the earth's climate - you will probably be dead before it really kicks in so why worry anyway? Keep on guzzling folks.....
sonny, london,
Has anyone calculated how much petrol and other fuels will be expended in getting all of the people to the concerts, housing them, poured into electricity during the concerts, and getting people home again? Why not have everyone stay home during the concert and just devote all of the money going into this amusement to a worthy cause?
James, Jacksonville, Illinois U. S.
The temperature of Mars is increasing in line with the Earth's because of the way the martians live.
Al Gore should be sent to Mars to tell the martians how irresponsible their lifestyle is.An inconvenient trip for Al but also a chance to become the saviour of two planets.(And if the martians don´t have a planetary computer network yet ,Al can invent it for them as he has claimed to have done here on Earth.)
Mauri Ahlaja, Turku, Finland
dasmb, Albany, NY.....an what made the last Ice Age disappear........?
Phil, Preston,
The world has been terrified by small groups of murderous Islamic fundamentalists, hang on , you haven't seen anything yet from environmental fundamentalists!
James Wong, Macau,
How much energy does 50 million televisions expend? Now throw in 5 million state-of-the-art sound systems with 100 watt surround sound speakers . Include in your calculations, the two or three million VCRs, DVRs and cable boxes. These activists have a funny way of telling us how important climate change is.
Maybe next time, they'll cut down a few thousand trees to demonstrate how important it is to save the rainforest.
Morgan Nec, Harrisburg, USA
I'll be doing my part in this very serious enterprise. I'll be investing in my own carbon offsets. A new Al Gore Wall Street Stock idea offers offsets based on farmers burning their gaseous cow's methane right at the source. It is a process that is being perfected at this moment.
The first farmer caught his barn on fire when one of his cows let loose with a particularly forceful explosion of methane over the farmer's BIC lighter. The flame shot ten feet catching a bale of hay on fire. The farmer suffered singed eyebrows and community embarrassment.
Dan Hanover, Tarrytown, USA
Speaking as a "gas-guzzling" American, I am all for anything that can reduce the pollutants in the air for general health, but global warming is nothing more than an excuse for the redistribution of wealth(via carbon tax). If any of these celebrity activists including Gore were actually serious about climate change, they would give up their jets, their huge limousines and their multi-mansion lifestyles. Rather than give up, they hand money over to the con artists running the carbon credit companies to get their blessing and make themselves feel good.
When they tell everyone to reduce your global footprint, they don't actually mean themselves, they just mean the rest of you peasants.
Morgan Nec, Harrisburg, US
The artists and politicians involved with Live Earth envision it as a great symbol of support for climate change, and maybe it is, but what's more important is their agile response to cries of hypocrisy by climate change critics and environmentalists alike.
Big festivals are here to stay; they're exciting and profitable. Pushing promoters to create festivals that have a lower environmental impact is a good thing. Really, it doesn't make sense to ferry Al Gore back and forth from the UK...and yet, without criticism, nobody would have really seen a problem with it. We have all this great efficiency technology and it's useless without the will to put it to use -- a will that won't exist until somebody demands it.
Oh, and as for climate change being due to solar output: there is no strong evidence for this, the studies that suggest it have been summarily debunked, and the vast majority of climate research has shown this. Sorry man. Science sez you wrong!
dasmb, Albany, NY,
We have been offered a choice, a chance. I am now with you... When you seek me, then you shall find mankind's salvation. We will solve the issues at hand with unifying solutions, and fuel a future, in which we all will proudly participate. An abundant future awaits us all. My message must be spoken aloud and spread all over the World, God's chosen King, I will complete our childhood.
Casey O, Chattanooga, Tennessee, USA
Sam Young in Paris is my new hero for his comments!
I am looking forward to about ten years from now when all these people (particularly Hollywood) look back and realize how easily led they are. I see no reason for why we shouldn't be doing everything we can to get off oil it IS being used at an insustainable rate and makes us dependent on unreliable regions of the world. Cleaning up our air in an economically responsible way could only be to our benefit too, however, many people have lost sight of reason and jump on the shrill, self-righteous bandwagon driven by Gore.
Marianne, Cincinnati,
Wouldn't it be better for the planet if they didn't hold the concerts at all and used the money to do something like plant trees or provide grants to people to assist them in making their homes more energy efficient?
David, Houston, TX, USA
I wonder if these people who are so concerned with global warming realize just how much green house gases they will release into the atmosphere during these global warming concerts? I'm sure they will all come by private jet, and limosine. stay in thier air conditioned trailors, have thier 20 person entorage etc. etc. It is all so rediculous. Lets do something about real problems like Darfur and AIDS. Global Warming, another Hollywood flavor of the month! Whatever happened to the Bird Flu pandemic that was supposed to wipe out the world????
tom, NJ, USA
I say idiots that fall for the drivel of A Gores big concert.
News break. The earth has warmer periods and the earth has colder periods. Earth shattering wasn't it. And I was taught about it 45 years ago in elementary school.
So you can be a big energy hog and then make it ok by waving the magical carbon credit wand. Many years have passed since I gave up believing in the tooth fairy but then, all this stuff is to sway the mind of kids.
Soon Gore will tell his flock that the melting of ice on Mars is our problem because of our reflective atmosphere and will order the atmosphere to be contained. And all his followers will go Oooooo.
Tommy Ton, york, pa
What a novel idea, "Rock Stars against warming temperatures!". How appropriate that Spinal Tap be involved. This has gone from absurd to amusing.
William P., NYC, USA
People were "acting for the good" when they wrongly banned DDT. Millions of African deaths directly attributed to this action later, Africa and other third world nations are begging and pleading: PLEASE, no more acting for the good. We'll be better off if you don't.
This global warming nonsense is a scam of global proportions. Anyone buying into it should have their sanity questioned.
Kevin, NC, USA,
"To combat criticism of their own damaging effect on the environment, the organisers will pay at least £1m in carbon credits" Nice..the real "Inconvenient Truth" is that Al Gore owns a company that sells so called "carbon credits" how nice of him to promote a world wide concert and then sell them credits that will make him even more wealthy. Gore is the world's biggest charlatain. But, as is often said, "there is a sucker born every minute". Gore is capitalizing on a world full of suckers.
Jeff, Atlanta, U.S.A./GA
But...But...what happened to the Global COOLING and impending ICE AGE i was suppose to be terrified of in the 70's????
dan, holt, mi usa
So, how many televisions will have to be on to view this event? If average viewership is a million households watching (probably vastly understated) you've got 24 hours of 25" televisions being on per household, or 24 * 150 * 1,000,000 or 3.6 billion watts.
brian, belmont, USA, California
Are you 'avin a laugh?
J Sumner, Nashville , USA
Any musicians who are niaive enough to sign up to Gore's propaganda show should demand a share of the future profits from his environmental consultancy company.
And can someone explain to me why anyone would have the lights on in summer? Gore really is a clueless showman.
Chris, Birmingham, UK
Didier Niclaes:
"I really admire the action of Al gore and her/his followers"
You are mistaken, Al Gore is not a hermaphrodite. She is a beautiful lady.
Felix, Nottingham,
I really admire the action of Al gore and her/his followers like Madonna.
These people are acting for the good. But in this world, even the most beautiful acts are criticised. The "anti-all" just deserve contemption.
Didier Niclaes, Brussels, Belgium
Like many others, I believe that man-induced climate change is a hoax. It is due to solar activity as expressed by highly respected scientists and climatologists. But I do see the point in reducing CO2 emissions but for health's sake and to make sure we are no longer reliant on oil in 20 years time. But who is going to get the Americans, the Chinese and the Indians to cut back? The UK emits 2% of the world's emissions we are told, so let us back off a bit and stand up to these people who are making profit, either in cash, political or misplaced emotion, out of promoting the current fad. All we are doing is causing Third World countries where they are destroying their own environment to make extravagant claims for "damages" on the West.
The climate change band-wagoneers have not yet explained why the surface of Mars is increasing in temperature in line with the Earth's yet.
B J Deller, Marbella, Spain
Personally, i make a point of wasting energy, just to annoy the climate change people. I will continue to do so until this climate change hysteria has returned to the gutter from where it came.
That's my say had.
And i very much doubt that i am the only person fed up to the teeth with these tree huggers.
Merci
Sam Young, Paris, France
It is amazing how folks just keep talking about a false premise/issue of CO2 causing climate change. They are both poorly educated and misled by a party line or economic criminals.
Current incompetent stories regarding CO2 Causing Climate Change are a fraud.
When you base anything on a false premise everything else that follows is false. CO2 causing climate change IS a false premise.
Consensus is NOT science. Educate, inform yourself, take a 9th grade science class.
Stop listening to folks that have a financial interest in the subject. Unfortunately, many have learned to spin information, thusly have become intellectually and academically dishonest.
Information Vetting: I have no financial interest in this subject.
Dr Coles, Los Angeles, USA
Since when, Ben of Wilmslow, has any Chancellor needed an excuse to tax us? If he doesn't apply Green taxes (and he isn't!) he will tax something else. It is also worth remembering that taxes don't just go into a black hole, they are used to pay for services - hospitals, schools etc - that we need, and which we shout very loudly if we don't get.
I do agree that the tax take from business is derisory: about 8% of the total I believe.
Bill Linton, London,
This is surreal - to call it funny, would be to downplay the irony!
We must be hitting the point when Joe Public says Stop, no more!
We know its getting a little warmer, please don't try and cash in on it any more. Al Gore, Madonna, and politicians of all parties are expert at jumping on and off bandwagons, and this one is no exception.
I expect in about 5 years, we will be looking at the global warming hype as another example of cashing in on a public fear.
Maybe we should have a show to celebrate that - call it live hype or something!
Oli Rhys, Deeside, Wales
I think this carbon footprint hype is a load of twaddle; simply designed to extract more money from the ordinary joe. I do agree that global warming is happening, but to blame us is a step too far. Global warming has been around long before man and the industrial revolution. The only reason the British government tax joe public is because to tax big business would hurt the economy too much, so they don't. That's why aviation fuel is still tax free.
ben, wilmslow, cheshire