Katherine Ashenburg
Enter our Snapshots of Summer photography competition

For the modern, middle-class North American, “clean” means that you shower and apply deodorant each and every day without fail. For the aristocratic 17th-century Frenchman, it meant that he changed his linen shirt daily and dabbled his hands in water, but never touched the rest of his body with water or soap. For the Roman in the first century, it involved two or more hours of splashing, soaking and steaming the body in water of various temperatures, raking off sweat and oil with a metal scraper, and giving himself a final oiling - all done daily, in company and without soap.
Even more than in the eye or the nose, cleanliness exists in the mind of the beholder. Every culture defines it for itself, choosing what it sees as the perfect point between squalid and over-fastidious.
It follows that hygiene has always been a convenient stick with which to beat other peoples, who never seem to get it right. The outsiders usually err on the side of dirtiness. The ancient Egyptians thought that sitting a dusty body in still water, as the Greeks did, was a foul idea. Late 19th-century Americans were scandalised by the dirtiness of Europeans; the Nazis promoted the idea of Jewish uncleanliness. At least since the Middle Ages, European travellers have enjoyed nominating the continent's grubbiest country - the laurels usually went to France or Spain. Sometimes the other is, suspiciously, too clean, which is how the Muslims, who scoured their bodies and washed their genitals, struck Europeans for centuries. The Muslims returned the compliment, regarding Europeans as downright filthy.
Most modern people have a sense that not much washing was done until the 20th century, and the question I was asked most often while writing this book always came with a look of barely contained disgust: “But didn't they smell?” As St Bernard said, where all stink, no one smells. The scent of one another's bodies was the ocean our ancestors swam in, and they were used to the everyday odour of dried sweat. It was part of their world, along with the smells of cooking, roses, garbage, pine forests and manure. Twenty years ago, aircraft, restaurants, hotel rooms and most other public indoor spaces were thick with cigarette smoke. Most of us never noticed it. Now that these places are usually smoke-free, we shrink back affronted when we enter a room where someone has been smoking. The nose is adaptable, and teachable.
To modern Westerners, our definition of cleanliness seems inevitable, universal and timeless. It is none of these things, being a complicated cultural creation and a constant work in progress.
The most menacing aspect of the smells that came with poor-to-middling hygiene was that, as we were constantly warned, we could be guilty of them without even knowing it. There was no way we could ever rest assured that we were clean enough. For me, the epitome of feminine daintiness was the model who posed on the cover of a Kotex pamphlet about menstruation, titled: You're a Young Lady Now. This paragon, a blue-eyed blonde wearing a pageboy hairdo and a pale blue shirtwaist dress, had clearly never had a single extraneous hair on her body and smelled permanently of baby powder. I knew I could never live up to her immaculate blondness, but much of my world was telling me I had to try.
While ads for men told them they would not advance at the office without soap and deodorant, women fretted that no one would want to have sex with them unless their bodies were impeccably clean. No doubt that's why the second most frequent question I heard during the writing of this book - almost always from women - was a rhetorical: “How could they bear to have sex with each other?”
In fact, there's no evidence that the birth rate ever fell because people were too smelly for copulation. And, although modern people have a hard time accepting it, the relationship between sex and odourless cleanliness is neither constant nor predictable. The ancient Egyptians went to great lengths to be clean, but both sexes anointed their genitals with perfumes designed to deepen and exaggerate their natural aroma.
Most ancient civilisations matter-of-factly acknowledged that, in the right circumstances, a gamey, earthy body odour can be a powerful aphrodisiac. Napoleon and Josephine were fastidious for their time in that they both took a long, hot, daily bath. But Napoleon wrote to Josephine from a campaign: “I will return to Paris tomorrow evening. Don't wash.” As I read about cleanliness, people began taking me aside and confessing things: several didn't use deodorant, just washed with soap and water; some didn't shower or bathe daily. Two writers told me separately that they had a washing superstition: as the end of a long project neared, they stopped washing their hair and didn't shampoo until it was finished. One woman confided that her husband of some 20 years takes long showers at least three times a day: she would love, she said wistfully, to know what he “really” smells like.
The surreptitious way people revealed their deviations to me indicates how thoroughly we have been conditioned: to risk smelling like a human is a misdemeanour, and the goal is to smell like an exotic fruit or a cookie. The standard we read about in magazines and see on television is a sterilised and synthetic one.
What could be more routine and apparently banal than taking up soap and water and washing yourself? Yet it echoes, and links us to, some of the most profound feelings and impulses we know. In almost every religion, water and cleansing are resonant symbols - of grace, of forgiveness, of regeneration. Worshippers around the world wash themselves before prayer, whether literally, as the Muslims do, or more metaphorically, as when Catholics dip their fingers in holy-water fonts at the entrance to the church.
The archetypal link between dirt and guilt, and cleanliness and innocence, is built into our language - perhaps into our psyches. We talk about dirty jokes and laundering money. When we step too close to something morally unsavoury at a business meeting or a party, we say: “I wanted to take a shower.” Pontius Pilate washed his hands after condemning Jesus to death, and Lady Macbeth claims, unconvincingly: “A little water clears us of this deed,” after persuading her husband to kill Duncan. Baths and immersions also have a natural kinship with rites of passage, the ceremonies that mark the transition from one stage of life to the next - from being an anonymous infant to a named member of the community, from singlehood to marriage, from life to death.
One of the most widespread rites of passage involves bathing the dead, an action that serves no practical purpose but meets deep, symbolic ones. The final washing given to Jewish corpses is a solemn ceremony performed by the burial society, in which the body is held upright while 24 quarts of water are poured over it. Other groups - the Japanese, the Irish, the Javanese - enlist the family and close neighbours to wash the dead. All have a sense that respect for the dead means that he or she must be clean for the last journey, to the last resting place. Climate, religion and attitudes to privacy and individuality also affect the way we clean ourselves. For many in the modern West, few activities demand more solitude than washing our naked bodies. But for the ancient Romans, getting clean was a social occasion, as it can still be for modern Japanese, Turks and Finns.
In cultures where group solidarity is more important than individual- ity, nudity is less problematic and scrubbed, odourless bodies are less necessary. As these values shift, so does the definition of “clean”.
©Katherine Ashenburg 2008
Extracted from Clean: An Unsanitised History of Washing, by Katherine Ashenburg, to be published on March 20 by Profile Books, £12.99.
Available for £11.69 from Times BooksFirst: 0870 1608080; timesonline.co.uk/booksfirst
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the collective power of smart thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Flip MinoHD Camcorder
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
42,945
2008
71,450
Car Insurance
Not Specified
MI6
UK-based
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Save up to £1,000 per couple with Elite Vacations at the five-star Constance Lemuria Resort
and do the British Isles this Summer.
Save up to 60% with Oxford Hotels and Inns
Try our inspiring luxury holidays to the Indian Subcontinent and South East Asia.
Great offers available
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
most commercial products with fragrance make me ill. i am allergic to a lot of things in shampoo and conditioner also.
lately i have resorted to using water only for shampooing and on my face and body i use coconut oil/brown sugar scrub that i make myself. well, my skin and hair have never been happier!!! my hair is finally shiny and thick and soft.
and it doesn't smell. if i want it to smell like flowers or something i take a few drops of essential oil on my damp hands and smooth it on the ends.
djh/austin, tx
dj horne, austin, TX
How refreshing! I never cease to be amazed by the amount of money that my housemates waste on 'revolutionary' products intended to "restore the natural oils" to their poor, parched skin and hair.... which have had afore-mentioned natural oils stripped from them by the harsh detergents in other, equally expensive products!!! How completely we have all been conned - big pharmaceutical companies would have us believe that each square inch of our bodies requires a unique moisturiser - and I know people who obediently go out and buy 'specialist' products... including one specifically for the soles of the feet! Snap out of it people - drink more water and learn to love your own scent :-)
E Butler, London, (Australian)
I live in the sub-tropics and don't use deodorant. The smell of my sweat affirms to me that I've done some modicum work on any given day.
Mark, Fort Myers, FL
Well yes, but didn't the toffs in the middle ages carry an orange spiked with cloves and othersuch to fend off the noxious vapours of the great unwashed? And just where did the term nosegay originate?
For my own part, the rank stench of the middle-aged and up in early and not-so-early post-war England (a product, perhaps, of water rationing during the war), made me vow at a very tender age that I would never be of their number!
Archie, Thrapston, England
Why do you say, 'She forgot to mention this, she forgot to mention that'? This is an excerpt from a book. Have you read it all?
Flo, Exeter,
Keep in mind that this article is condensed from a 368-page book, so omissions are necessary for its publication in article format. Still, I expected to see at least brief mention of Hindu practices as well as Native American sweat lodges.
Lisa, Richmond, USA Kentucky
Japanese communal bath (sento) are not primarly for relaxing but for washing, though they indeed have a big bath just for relaxing. Onsen (hot springs) are mainly for relaxing but then again, you have to wash before getting in.
As someone mentioned, the smell of cleanliness is taught indeed. Being rather olfactorily sensitive, the "disinfectant smell" of deodorant that many Americans consider as a clean smell is as offensive to me than the smell of sweaty fellow basketball players after a game. Many Japanese do agree on that!
On the other hand, nothing beats the smell of a sweaty woman after love so it's really a question of context... :-)
Also contrary to popular belief, people in the Middle Ages bathed quite often. Public bathes were all over the place. They were also used as brothels which lead to their downfall.
The 17th century was the era when people didn't bath for SANITARY reasons. Baths and water was thought to carry diseases and so on.
Jon Jon, Tokyo,
she neglects to mention that the early french DID notice one another's smells - they held perfume soaked cloths to their faces, almost constantly.
altgrave
berkeley, california
matthew, berkeley,
Actually to the best of my knowledge, Japanese communal baths are for relaxing, not washing. You wash in a shower (that is not necessarily communal) before you get into the communal bath. Not to do so would be offensive -- you need to be clean before you get in there!
Mrs Fisch, BG, Italy
I shower twice daily, washing my hair and body with plain water. I use gentle soap on my face because that's the only way to get the skin wet enough to rub the dead skin off. I have never used deodorant in my life. My hair looks and smells clean and I have virtually no body odor. And I live in a place where the temperature reaches 120F/50C in the summer and I teach yoga classes. I eat a normally healthy diet that includes plenty of meat, so it's not that. I'm convinced that scrubbing the natural bacteria off your skin makes room for the smelly kind. It really helps to have a detachable shower head so that I can get all up in there, but plain water is an amazing natural cleanser.
Antinous, Palm Springs, California
This is a bit western centric isn't it? Hindus have been bathing for millenia before the muslims and christians thought about it :-) Mohenjo Daro and other archeological digs throughout india have shown extensive plumbing set ups comprable to "modern western" style plumbing. A Hindu must wash prior to performing puja, which is done at least once if not twice a day. Why isn't that mentioned?
Sri, Baltimore,
Memole,in the Perfume book ,if the victims weren't female they wouldn't have been killed.
Line Larsen, Aarhus, Danmark
Our reactions to "good" smells are also taught. People are now taught is that perfumed bodies, perfumed clothing, perfumed rooms, and all sorts of perfumed products smell "good." To me, most of these chemical odors are way too strong to avoid and they smell disgusting. And you have to wonder what kind of cancer they are causing. Perfumes are now found in mother's milk. Our fear of reality even extends to fear of smelling anything real.
Leslie, Philadelphia, USA
having lived amongst Europeans for years, I'll take the American way to cleanliness, nevertheless!
Ben , alexandria, VA
The American inventor Thomas Alva Edison, the world record patent rights holder (1093 inventions), very seldom bathed and lived for days in his Menlo Park laboratory. His body odor impregnated by chemical products was said to be intolerable and he attributed his inventive gifts to his lack of cleanliness. His famous phrase âGenius is 99 percent perspiration and 1 percent inspirationâ was not a metaphor but truly literal.
Rodrigo R. de Moraes
Brazil
rodrigo r. de moraes, Ribeirão Preto, São Paulo, Brazil
It is interesting to note that studies are showing that the rise in dementia, forgetfulness, and Alzheimer's in modern societies may, in part, be due to the lack of stimulation to the olfactory sense. Aroma is one of the key factors in creating strong memories and boosting mental power. Our sanitized world is, perhaps, not all that it is sold to be.
The power of pheromones and scent (aromas) have already been proven to govern the sex drive in humans.
Ah, turn off the central heat and air conditioning, open the windows, and breathe deeply. I miss men who have an aroma that can stir me.
Katherine, Central Virginia, USA
As a Secondary School teacher, I know that I have great difficulty convincing some of my teen-age pepils that each one of us has got a body odour - that it is only bad BO that is the problem for most of our overly-sensitive noses!
I would also say to H Grant that one of the problems in our modern, ultra-cleanliness obsessed, culture is the fact that we constantly kill off even the "good" bactria. This results in an immuno-deficiency which, while not as serious as AIDS, can leave us more vulnerable to a plethora of minor ailments that our less-wll-washede ancestors dealt with without even knowing it!
C.B.Ross, Motherwell, Scotland
take the 'Perfume' book... if the victim washed obsessively she wouldn't have been killed.
memole, Cambridge,
I'm sure it's right that if everyone smelled, we would not notice it any more. But I wonder whether people who washed very rarely (such as the 17th century Frenchman in the article) got ill more often? Was their skin crawling with bacteria? Did they get stomach upsets, skin infections, bladder infections all the time? Or did they develop a robust immunity?
H Grant, Germany,
She forgot to mention the bidet, invented by the French but mostly used by Italians.
F, Cardiff,