Alex Bellos
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes

I recently struck up a conversation with a woman in my local takeaway. The banter began to run out of steam, so I switched the subject to maths. This uncharted chat-up territory. I asked her to doodle on a napkin. Without taking the pen off the paper, she drew a pattern of consecutive loops, then joined the line back to where she started. Then she criss-crossed the squiggle with an open grid of parallel lines. I asked her the minimum number of colours she would need to fill in the doodle completely, so that no two areas with the same colour were adjacent to each other.
She hesitated. “Four?”
The answer, in fact, is only two. She stared at the napkin in disbelief, then started to shade it in. Her eyes lit up as she realised that it was true.
My experiment was a success. Yes, I got her number. But, more importantly, it reinforced my belief that maths can be fascinating to people who would usually claim to have no interest in it. You don't need to understand the proof of the two-colour doodle theorem to appreciate the “wow” of seeing such an inky mess reduced to a simple black and white mosaic.
At school, those who shine at maths are seen as socially retarded, more comfortable around numbers than around people. I'm a card-carrying mathmo: I studied maths at university and am writing a book on it. On balance, however, I prefer people to numbers. In fact, the general perception that maths is just numbers is part of the problem with the prejudice against us. My mental arithmetic is bad (and I'm not proud of it) but this does not restrict my love of the subject.
Maths, for me, is about seeing the world in terms of patterns and symbols and marvelling at how they interrelate. Recursive language and a self-reflecting consciousness are uniquely human; so is the ability to think mathematically. I'd argue that the most impressive, and creative, expressions of pure thought in human history have been mathematical. That's pretty cool.
OK, as an opening gambit the line is not exactly dynamite. Yet maths has definitely helped me conversationally. For a start, mathematicians have a refined sense of humour. It is no coincidence that many writers on The Simpsons are maths and computer science graduates. One of the most basic forms of proof is proof by contradiction. This is when you prove the truth of statement A by assuming that A is false, and then show that the falsity of A leads to an impossibility. This is precisely the structure of many jokes - start with a premise that is a slight modification of reality, and bring out the absurdity of the consequences. Doh!
Mathematicians are good at bashing ideas around - negating them, turning them inside out, pulverising them and rearranging the pieces. Sometimes the result is meaningful, sometimes it isn't. And even then it has its rewards. Lewis Carroll, the father of nonsense verse, was a mathematician. Actually, he was a logician - they are even more hilarious.
Mathematicians are playful. I don't mean by this the cliché of the wacky boffin with his Van de Graaff generator hair (nothing reinforces maths as boring so much as someone shouting “fun!”). French mathematicians in the 17th century analysed their gambling habits and ended up inventing the science of probability, a basic understanding of which is as crucial in the modern world as the ability to remember one's times tables.
For me, maths becomes most exciting when it touches on deep philosophical issues. We are taught that maths is a rigid and consistent system. Well, sorry to break the news, but it isn't. Many weirdnesses lie within it. An example: there are two types of infinity, one bigger than the other. Actually, there are an infinite number of infinities, all of different size. That's fascinating, and I would probably bring it up on the second date.
One paradox connected with the British disrespect for maths is our veneration of those with musical talent. Many mathematicians are musical and many musicians have good intuitive understanding of maths. Both subjects involve a search for elegance, an improvisational creativity and a familiarity with symmetries and rules. In terms of “cool music”, Britain punches above its weight. Perhaps attitudes to maths would change if just one rock star admitted that he spent his time at the back of the tour bus doing Su Doku puzzles.
It wouldn't make him a pariah. Researching my maths book I have learnt that there is no social skill more guaranteed to charm than the ability to fold two business cards into a tetrahedron. Maths can be a powerful aphrodisiac. I now use it only sparingly in social situations.
Prime example: try this test yourself
Proof by contradiction is one of a mathematician's most powerful tools. Its most famous use is in proving that there are infinitely many prime numbers. A prime number is a whole number that can be divided only by itself and 1. So 7 is prime because it cannot be divided by anything else, but 8 is not because it can also be divided by 4 and 2. Also, all numbers can be reduced to their primes. 8 could be 2x2x2, but 7 could only be 7x1.
To prove that there are infinite prime numbers, we first assume that there are finite prime numbers, then try to show that this leads to an impossible situation. So, assume that there are finite prime numbers. There could be seven, or a hundred million. For this example, let's say that there are four. Now, imagine another number which is all existing prime numbers multiplied together, plus 1. As we are mathematicians now, let us call that number “p”. So in our example, p would be 2x3x5x7+1, or 211.
If we divide p by any of these other prime numbers, we are never going to get a whole number. We will always have 1 left over - a remainder. Check for yourself: in our example, divide 211 by 2, and you get 3x5x7+ (or 105 remainder 1). Divide it by 3, or 5, or 7, and that remainder will still be there.
Remember, all numbers can be reduced to their prime factors, without any remainders anywhere. So, either p is prime, or there is another prime that we haven't yet figured out. Either way, our initial assumption is false.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Notice that the woman was able to find out for herself. Consider what happens in our schools, where there is a perceived need to 'pass'. Ask children if they enjoy Mathematics. Look at a GCSE paper, where it is possible to 'pass' by rote learning, with little understanding. Enjoyable?
Gordon Cardew, NORWICH, UK
The problem is that people say maths is cool (which it is) but they don't warn people that it can require a lot of effort (which it does). So many people are put of because they think they're not smart enough, when in fact they just haven't tried hard. It's like football: you need to practice a lot!
David, London, England
Maths is cool. Being smart is cool. As long as you aren't arrogant about it. It's only when you're pretentious or arrogant that you stop being cool.
Mat, Brighton,
The answer to the map-question (more generic) is however four :)
Annette , Bergen, Norway
Did you see World Maths Day http://www.worldmathsday.com ? Kids from all over the world answered over 180 MILLION questions - now that is seriously cool and kids went beserk.
Maths can definitely be cool - but not if it is presented in a boring, old-fashioned way.
Feralpossum, Sydney, Australia
What maths is used to build bridges - What a question! Where do i start? Not much maths in painting it but it would be hard to meet the conflicting demands of strength, weight, aerodynamics, cost, style, life expectency and pretty much every desirable characteristic without maths.
Tim Hurdle, Bristol, England
Actually Frank, Maths itself, while wonderful, is merely a language built on a series of assumptions (or "axioms"), and as such represents a theory, not truth. Maths is pretty powerful yes, just not absolutely indisputable; google "Godel" for more...
Richard, London,
"If someone explained to me what good is it knowing what a prime number is, I might find it worthwhile"
They have many uses - Crypography being just one them.
Steffy, London,
An excellent article. There have been some very silly comments about the decline in British maths just lately. As a retired maths teacher I can confirm that standards have gone down and poor leadership in maths education has created a dreadful exam system. The maths modules are a total failure.
Dr Les Nelson, Mezerville, France
Carol:
Conic sections (from geometry-ellipses, hyperbolae, parabolae) are all used in construction esp bridges. Algebraic codes that correct themselves when data is missing are used to transfer data to your computer. Algebraic algorithms are used to compress and encrypt data (using prime numbers).
Kevin, Salisbury, UK
How would you prove that all numbers can be reduced to their primes?
Jo, Orpington, United Kingdom
Maths can be both practical and fun. From everyday things like how to get the biggest pizza slice, to designing train timetables and building bridges. It's handy in finding a job too. Having an affinity for maths led me to become an actuary. With maths, the possibilities are limitless.
Henry, London, UK
I'm always puzzled when people begin to ask the question (or pass the remark) "what's the practical application for knowing calculus, number theory, etc." The other argument is what is the practical application of studying English Literature?
Mike, Leeds,
What Alex is using is my LEAST favorite form of math. I can not stand discrete math. While it may have its uses in probability, set theory, proving that something is K-colourable, and algorithm analysis (Thats the Big O for us computer nerds), I would still much rather take a triple integral.
Adam, Lovleand, OH, USA
Mathematics is the only indisputable truth that human beings know.
Frank Upton, Solihull,
Carol, does your objection to maths (that maths isn't necessarily practical) apply to everything (music, fashion, art, food, happiness - all of which are not always purely practical?
Steve, Altrincham,
I agree Peter Athey, Kids nowadays are somewhat more interested in the bizare. One hundred years ago a child may understand logarithms but if he saw a whirling computer screen saver, hed probably throw up and burn you as a witch. The same with Physics, out with Mechanics and in with quantum theory.
Zeus Dormer, stockholm, sweden
As a drilling engineer, here is my brief job spec: Create a 3D mathematical representation of all physical occurrences 6 miles underground: location of the bit in 3D space; torque at bit; hydraulics to clean the hole; pressures; safety margins etc. The answer is worth $50 million (USD).
gmac, Kassel, Germany
Carol from Paris should know that without prime numbers we simply wouldn't have the crytographic systems which make secure credit card transactions possible. Look it up - it's a fascinating subject and and not difficult to follow in principle at least.
Alleagra, London, UK
Maths is great - from making money to sailing - if you want any child to get into geometry get them navigating or hunting for treasure (on land or sea) taking bearings, measuring distances and angles. My thanks to my father for teaching me to navigate and to Mr James Alan Price for making maths fun.
Huw Sayer, Norwich, England
Certainly maths and music go hand in hand. This fact is seen by looking at mp3 technology which uses matrix cosine transforms (MDCT), a direct application of trigonometry, to decompose and reconstruct the harmonics of a sound signal into its respective subands. Maths + code = iPod.
Stuart, Glasgow, UK
If someone explained to me what good is it knowing what a prime number is, I might find it worthwhile. If maths were taught explaining what practical application each theory could be used for then people might find it interesting. What maths were used to build famous bridges for example ?
Carol, Paris, France
I am fascinated by geometry and especially the qualities and relationships of integers (number theory).I completed a maths degree 8 years ago and hated every minute if it. Apart from about 2, all the lecturers were completely uninspiring,socaially inept dullards.Alex Bellos is a rare breed, trust me
Kevin, Salisbury, UK
There IS great FUN of maths. If kids were introduced to algebra at 6 years old, when they have no fear of the abstract, and before mathphobia takes hold, there would be double the number of competent numerophiles in their teens.
Brian May, lead guitarist of Queen, recently got his PhD in Physics.
Peter Athey, Paris,