Alice Thomson
Win VIP tickets

The children of De Burght School in Amsterdam walk past the red-light district to their classrooms every day, past the “Peep Shows, Live Girls,” the risqué underwear shops and the newsagents selling teen magazines with free condoms. At school the five-year-olds play mummies and daddies in the playground knowing what their parents did in bed last night.
Next year, 12-year-old Sasha explains to me, they will learn how to put a condom on a broomstick (she says this without a trace of embarrassment, just a polite smile). Across the city, nine-year-old Marcus, who lives in a beautiful 18th-century house on a canal, has been watching a cartoon showing him how to masturbate. His sister, 11, has been writing an essay on reproduction and knows that it is legal for two consenting 12-year-olds to make love. Her favourite magazine, Girls, gives advice on techniques in bed, and her parents sometimes allow her to stay up to see a baby being born on the birthing channel.
Then there is Yuri, 16, who explains to me in perfect English that “anal sex hurts at the beginning but if you persevere it can be very pleasurable”. When I ask whether he is gay, he says “no” but he has watched a documentary on the subject with his parents.
Sex is everywhere in the Netherlands, yet the country has the lowest teenage pregnancy rate in the West and the lowest rates of sexually transmitted diseases among young people. Now Britain, with almost the highest rate of teenage pregnancy in Europe - five times higher than the Netherlands - wants to emulate its success.
Ministers are planning to introduce compulsory sex and relationships lessons for children from the age of 5 by 2010. There will be a “naming of parts” session in which children learn the correct words for vagina and testicles, and many will receive a sex education comic called Let's Grow with Nisha and Joe.
The Government has chosen the Dutch model rather than the Nordic way of tackling the subject of sex because the Netherlands, unlike Scandinavian nations, also manages to have one of the lowest abortion rates in Europe. In Britain, the number of abortions performed on under-16s rose by 10 per cent last year to 4,376.
So how do the Dutch do it? Siebe Heutzepeter, the headmaster of De Burght School, laughs at the idea that sex lessons are all children need to stop them becoming sexually active too young.
“We don't have formal sex education in primary schools,” he says. “The children talk about sex when they feel like it and when they want an explanation. We treat sex as a healthy physical activity between two adults who are in love. Every year we have teachers who are pregnant or getting married, whether they are gay or straight, so it is a good way to talk about adult relationships.”
Heutzepeter says that the Dutch are more relaxed than Britons in every aspect of their lives. “The English are embarrassed to talk about sex. They are too squeamish. Here adults and children are better educated. It would be unthinkable for a Dutch parent to withdraw their child from sex discussions. I have had only one Muslim mother who left halfway through a parents' talk on sex.”
He believes it is important to talk to children in a relaxed way about sex before they become self-conscious and embarrassed. “It is all about self-respect,” he said. “There is no point in telling children just to say ‘no' - this is a liberal country; you need to tell them why they are saying ‘no' and when to say ‘yes'.”
A series of books by Sanderijn van der Doef provides Dutch children with all they could need to know about sex. The book for five-year-olds has pictures on the cover of toddlers kissing each other on the lips. Inside, children are told why their mothers have breasts and shave their armpits, how smiley-faced sperm travel, how human beings prefer to lie on top of each other but dogs mate from behind, and what their father's penis looks like. The book for 11-year-olds shows a girl examining her genitals in a mirror, and explains about periods and the Pill.
Van der Doef is a star in her country and her manuals have become classics. Dutch parents read them to their children at bedtime, for information and enjoyment. “Here sex is a normal daily part of life, like shopping or football. In England it is a joke,” says the author. “My books teach children what adults do when they love each other and how babies are created. Children as young as 4 should know if they were born by Caesarean section or after artificial insemination. It is vital to be honest.”
John van der Woning, the head of one of Amsterdam's leading schools, Willemspark, says: “We teach children about all sorts of sex. We have lots of homosexual teachers and they celebrated a marriage of two female teachers recently. But we also try to teach the older children about the darker side of sex, about prostitution and child abuse. It's important to be open about the world.”
At secondary school the sex education is formalised and children are shown how to use various types of contraceptive, how to have “safe and pleasurable sex”, the importance of responsibility and how to recognise the symptoms of sexually transmitted diseases.
This openness seems to work. In Britain the average teenager loses his or her virginity at 16 - more than a year before the Dutch average of 17.7 years. About 93 per cent of young people in the Netherlands use contraception, compared with 53 per cent in Britain. A study of teenagers in both countries found that while boys and girls in the Netherlands gave “love and commitment” as the main reason for losing their virginity, boys in Britain cited peer pressure and physical attraction.
But Laura Watts, a British mother who has lived in the Netherlands for the past ten years, thinks that the lower rate of teenage pregnancy there may have more to do with family structure than with sex education. Dutch children are five times less likely to be living in a family headed by a lone parent, divorce rates are far lower and fewer mothers are in full-time employment.
“I think my eight-year-old son has probably learnt more about sex from David Attenborough than from school,” she says. “It is the family that makes the difference. Parents leave the office by 5pm in Holland and eat dinner with their children at 6pm. They then watch TV or play sport together, so they tend to be closer to their children and can guide them to do the right thing.”
Trudie, a fashion stylist, has always talked about sex with her daughter. When, at 16, her daughter asked her what sperm looked like, Trudie asked her husband to provide a sample. “My daughter walks past sex shops every day, the family watches sex scenes together on television and we try to be as open as possible. It's not considered smutty, as it is in England.”
Henny de Barbarison, a teacher at De Burght School, agrees: “My 18-year-old son still walks around the house naked - that's healthy. Everyone here is more relaxed.” Her female students are taught about “lover boys” who flirt with girls just to have sex with them, then pressurise them to sleep with other members of their group. Male students are taught about homosexual sex. There are no “no-go areas”.
Another reason why the teenage pregnancy rate is so low may be that in the Netherlands there is still a stigma attached to having a child before the age of 20. In Britain, a baby who can offer unconditional love, a free home away from parents and a cheque every month is not considered a disaster for a teenage girl. The Dutch Government still penalises single mothers under 18, who are expected to live with their parents if they become pregnant. Until six years ago the Government gave them no financial support.
Dutch children are taught that getting pregnant in their teens is a barrier to success. “I'm not prepared to risk messing up my life. I am strong enough to wait,” says Ruby, 12. “I want to be 19 and in love before I have sex,” says her friend Grace. Julia, 11, says: “My mother's best friend is gay, my hairdresser is gay, half my family seem to be gay. It's not an issue.”
Children in their final year of primary school have not been shielded from anything, but their teachers have continually reinforced the message that sex is about love and commitment. The pupils all agree that they will not sleep with anyone until they have finished secondary school and are in a serious relationship.
Vanessa Storm de Grave, a mother of four who works part-time for a publishing company, thinks that her compatriots may be more responsible about sex than the British because the Netherlands is a more religious country. “The family is very important here,” she says. “Almost no mothers work full time; they see their main role as educating their children.
“I hope I will teach my eldest son how to become a responsible man by example, but I tell him anything he wants to know. I have talked about homosexuality and why it means that you can't have babies, but he is more interested in sport.”
Doortje Braeker, a Dutch mother who works in Britain for the International Planned Parenthood Federation, says: “We are not scared of young people being sexually active and we want to make sure that their first experiences are safe and pleasurable. We are a Calvinist country so it is important that we don't have too many abortions, but the postwar generation also wants to have fun.”
Braeker was shocked when she first came to Britain. “Young girls here seem to have babies to prove that they are adults. In the Netherlands it would just prove how uneducated and naive you are,” she says. “There you can have a boy as a friend, here it's almost always about sex.”
Mena Laura Meyer, who produced the seven-part documentary series Sexy for Dutch TV last year, says that sex education is the least relevant aspect of the country's success. “All the children I talked to were quite dismissive about their sex education at school,” she says. “They appreciated knowing how to put on a condom but were more interested in the emotional than the physical side of sex.”
Her series, which addressed every issue from anal sex to S&M, was watched by more than a quarter of Dutch households. “All you watch in Britain are your soaps, which are all about single mums, and your wildlife documentaries, which just cover penguins mating,” she says. “Sex and relationships aren't government issues. Until the British can sit down together and watch programmes about masturbation and birth, you will never have a healthy attitude to sex.”
In Britain the Government has decided that schools must bear responsibility for sex education. Jim Knight, the Schools Minister, insists that from 2010 schools must make time for the new personal, social and health education (PSHE) syllabus. Children aged 5 to 7 will learn about feelings; those aged 8 to 11 will be taught about the biological aspects of sex. At secondary school they will learn about contraception and sexually transmitted diseases.
But maybe it's up to parents. Perhaps we should all be buying our toddlers Mummy Laid An Egg by Babette Cole, leaving condoms around the house, as one Dutch mother suggests, “to prompt discussions”, and sitting down to supper each evening to discuss our relationships.
One colleague attempted this, and her 12-year-old son asked her “how many positions are there?” in front of the babysitter. My eight-year-old asked me if it was more painful to wax my legs than to give birth.
But after my few days in the Netherlands, my children now understand where babies come from. It has marred the beginning of Dumbo when the storks come down from the clouds, but I hope it will turn them into more responsible adults.
Maybe, instead of expecting schools to teach children morality and the missionary position, the British should adopt a few other Dutch lessons. Employers could encourage staff to go home at 5pm for a family supper, parents could discuss contraception with their children, and the BBC could ask David Attenborough to turn his attention to human reproduction.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I find it interesting that when similiar programs are presented in the US, they never discuss the issues of sex as adults only, a love and committed relationship, and consequences. They only discuss the physical part. Maybe we should emulate the Dutch program and bring back the social stigma.
Jen Germain, Sierra Vista, USA
in my opinion the most convincing explantation for the lowest rate of teenage pregnancy is the limited support which the Dutch government offer. i commend this, too many people in Britain see babies as the most effective way of rapping the benefit system. there's no need to teach 5yr olds adult behv
Djihan , London,
I'm 25, I was educated in a catholic school and we were not taught about sex education either or STI's etc. I gradually learned for myself as a young teenager but not in a safe way either. I believe that if we were taught early there would'nt be as many pregnancies or diseases. New change NOW!
carol, ireland,
I think the Dutch have a calm, honest, level-headed approach to sex education. I wish that the USA would emulate it. A look at our teen statistics in pregnancy and disease demonstrates that our approach is not working. I bet the Netherlands have a lower teen suicide rate too.
Janet, Olympia, USA
Sounds like the Dutch are bored to death by sex, as it is discussed non-stop. Do they make time for any other subjects at school?
Chris, Sydney, Australia
I would suggest the key difference between us and the Dutch is the emphasis on family and relationships. If we try a Dutch-style sex education programme without first reforming the standing of family and loving relationships in our country, it will be a disaster. We have too much emphasis on sex.
Tim, Salisbury, UK
If the children who are taught sex education from a primary school age then they will grow up with no stigma attatched and by the time they have children surely they would not be uncomfortable discussing personal experiences or methods of contraception.
Roslyn, Glasgow, Scotland
Surely there is an argument for leaving a sense of mystique about some things. Sex is not repairing a car. It stops being sexy pretty fast when you chat about it with your Mum over breakfast, no? But Scandos and the Dutch reduce so much of life to a practical level, which makes them all so bland.
Giancarlo, Bath, England
Do the Dutch reward single mothers with housing and benefits? If not, could it be that this lack of incentive has more to do with pregnancy rates than a how-to manual?
Marcher Baron, Welsh Marches,
Dr O'connor ... it would be amazing how fast change would come if you kick out any group with diverse thoughts. Diversity always slows down any institution. But it's pretty selfish to favor your own life philosophy as though you were the standard and show such little tolerance for others.
Judy Crayton, Edwardsville, USA
"The Birds and the Bees and the Flowers and the
trees" (song) for youngsters of 5yrs.) would be too much for the Netherlands to understand, I would presume. Isabel Witty NZ
Desenstitising from LOVE is not an ideal progress
in the teaching of the specie Homo sapien male or
female. <<>>
Isabel Witty, Christchurch, New Zealand
As a Dutch student living in the UK, I am suprised how the attitude is about sex and how normal it is to have a child as a teenager. My parents taught me first to think of contraception before even thinking or have sex.
And Andrew NL is colder then the UK.. still think it's not normal
Leslie, bristol,
I'd prefer to stick to our system, thanks. Higher rates of teenage pregnancies is undesirable, but it's still miles better than sexualising children as the Dutch do.
S Foster, S Yorks, UK
Thank you, w, amsterdam.
As a single mother of a wilful 13 year old girl, I find it very hard here in Amsterdam. My girl knows about the dangers w. mentioned, but I still worry all the time about the things she and her friends get up to.Young people have a subculture which is becoming more sexual.
lucita, amsterdam, netherlands
Look, instead of speculative articles, why not see, across Europe, whether the number of hours of sex education per pupil or divorce rates correlate with increasing teenage preganancy rates?
Ged, paris,
This is the same kind of thinking that promoted a "European" model of drinking in this country - result? increased drunkeness and disorder in our cities. I found most of this article quite obscene and obviously exaggerated. As for the naked 18 year old - in our climate?
andrew milner, London, UK
Foucault's panopticon is in play here. The body becomes an end by itself. An end by itself, a relentless iterative loop that requires product deliverables emotional, physical and material. Needs acquire a larger than life individualised option.With the self for discovery means no need for outdoors.
A.V.Raman, Coventry, UK
In general the Dutch discus more sensible about any subject . Not just sex. There seems to be a strong culture of discussing all and everything under the sun. Sometimes it seems to be mandatory to reveal and have a debate about virtually every detail of life, which can be irritating at times.
robert, vancouver, bc
When it comes to teen pregnancies, I think the most important thing is we are told that we should be able to take care of ourselves before getting pregnant. That means finishing education and being able to get a job before living with your boyfriend and most certainly before getting a baby.
Hanneke Visser, The Hague, The Netherlands
Here in the U.S., my two cousins attended a private school that offered a graduated and fully comprehensive sex education program beginning in the 1st grade. By the age of 16, they had the most sensible and intelligent attitudes towards sex I've ever seen among teens. We need to start early.
Lili, Chicago, USA
My kid were taught by the school how to have sex at primary school, but to my horror they were not taught about contraception or how to avoid getting pregnant. Nor were they taught about sexually transmitted diseases and how to avoid catching them.
I taught them myself as the school was abysmal, the way the UK teaches kids about sex you would think they want the kids to get pregnant and infected. It's a shambles and makes me very angry.
Tiff, inverness, scotland
Meg from Washington DC: Most parents won't teach their children because they are too embarrassed. In England and America everybody is just hoping that someone else teaches our children or that they will figure it out on their own. It is a hopeless situation.
Matthew, New York City, USA
An interesting article most of which I want to agree with and have employed in this country, but we are talking about a massive cultural change. David Attenborough's programmes on sex education are more likely to be a rare occasion in many schools with ill-equipped teachers for this job.
Rodney S. Barker, Gainsborough, England UK
parents are best equipped to teach their own childern about sex who knows better the maturity of each child and their ability to cope with the information better than a parent? There's enough pressure on childern to grow up too fast without adding what is sometimes an opposing view to the familys.
Meg, washington dc, USA
Good article. And some predictable responses. It has always exasperated me that we look the USA 'abstinency' programmes (where the rate of teenage pregnancy is often 10 times what it is here) for guidance , rather than to Europe and their sensible system where pregnancy rates are so much lower.
John F, LONDON, uk
Well Rugerio, that's just the kind of attitude towards sex that was meant in the article. If you don't see that this has nothing to with morality or dignity, but everything with protecting the child, then you're the one that's completely blind to the truth. The statistics prove you wrong, dont they?
Markus, Bryne, Norway
There seem to be alot of exagerations in this article for instance, showing sperm from your husband to your daughter wont be called 'normal' by the majority of dutch people. Also the sentence about knowing it is legal for 2 consenting 12yo's to have sex is incorrect, age of consent in NL is 16 years
Tris, Breda, Netherlands
All this young age sex education is nothing more than brainwashing.The evil adults who like this want to take away a child's sense of morality and dignity as well as his innocence.
Saying that this has anything to do with the rates of promiscuity and sexuality is a complete blind to the truth.
rugerio, chester, england
We need this sort of honesty and self-respect in America.
Kiristen, Gainesville,
It's crap women in The Netherlands have lack of ambition. There are lots of women who have a full-time job. In fact, most of them have. Well maybe not most of the 50-year olds but it surely counts for the younger ones.
Jamie Thorpe, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
The key to our 'success'? Women in the Netherlands are well-educated but lack the ambition to persue a big carrier, that's why they all become part-time working, children-loving house-mothers. Religion has absolutely nothing to do with this, since the by far biggest part of our people is atheist.
S, Milan, Italy
I agree with most, but there are also some things exaggerated.
Like the television show that has been seen by more than a quarter of Dutch households, and not all schools in Holland work this way. But the family-values part is true, also in non-religious households.
Daan, Utrecht, Netherlands
Open-minded and selfrespect...Key elements that are being thaught in The Netherlands. That's very good.
But we also have problems, not all is well.
'Sex sells' by Mildred Roethof is a nice documentary portraying those problems. Thirteen year olds having sex for cigarettes or prepaid calling cards
w, amsterdam, the netherlands
Please do not forget this whole story is about children and parents living in the heart of Amsterdam. If you would talk to someone from the Dutch countryside, to a member of an etnic or religious minority, you would receive a quite different view.
Kees, Budapest, Hungary
I believe sex is in our society.In France they make us watch a delivery by the age of 14 in our sexual education year during biology course.,I can tell you it stop you to even think having unprotected sex.I can tell you too that most of my girlfriend since this event all want a c-sectio
Marie, London, UK
Absolutely, it should be the family's role to teach this. Sadly, many familes have failed. I doubt that central intervention will work though. It cannot teach what families should. Mothers forced out to work, rewards for a broken society - all causes, not just symptoms.
Richard, Leighton, UK
Bridget and the headmaster in the article have it right: self respect. For example, in the UK and Ireland you see many young girls on Saturday night in micro-miniskirts and very revealing tops. Dutch girls -generally- would consider themselves to be worth more than that.
Sophie, Ennis, Co. Clare, Ireland
Excellent article. I have always found the British attitude to sex rather infantile (although more liberal than the American attitude), and just goes to show that being completely open to children about sex does not always lead to promiscuity. However, I do agree that closer families are important.
John Harte, Bath, UK
A Dutch friend of mine says the same thing as the headmaster in this article. It is all about self-respect. Dutch teenagers think it is cool to work hard at school, do well, and have just one partner to whom one is respectful and faithful. To them teenage pregnancy is a sign of failure.
Bridget, London,
I don't think the Dutch attitude to teenage mothers is a bad thing. If having a child wasn't a potential means to getting their own place, I'm sure a lot of young girls would think twice.
It is depressing how so many areas traditionally learnt within the family are having to be institutionalised.
Philippa, London,
As a Dutch mother living in the UK, I couldn't agree more. The British attitude towards sex and sex education is squeamish and not condusive to a open ongoing dialogue within the family. And that's the point- families have the main role to play unlike here, where it's seen as the schools job.
Elle, Surrey,