Kenneth Denby in Pyapon, Burma
Get 20% off your bill at Pizza Express

We saw the first one a few minutes downriver, no more than five hundred yards from the quayside and the busy town centre of the river port of Pyapon. He was caught in the crook of a toppled tree, floating in the water on his back with his arms spreadeagled - the naked, decaying remains of a drowned man.
There was another corpse a few yards down, and then another, and then three more close together. Number six was recognisably that of a woman, with a green undergarment still clinging to her; number seventeen was a young girl. Close by was a dead buffalo, and what I mistakenly took to be a coconut or a drowned animal. “Khalaylay,” said the boatman, correcting me. A baby.
We chugged gently down the river, past the devastation of Cyclone Nargis, which passed almost directly over head a week ago this morning. Warehouses had their roofs ripped off, 50 foot boats had been picked up by the storm surge and deposited a hundred yards inland, and every few yards were the sunburned, distended bodies of the storm’s human victims. In 25 minutes, I counted 23 of them. And then I stopped counting.
Until yesterday, this disaster has had an unreal quality. The physical damage to trees, fields and buildings is overwhelmingly obvious. Refugees are living in schools and monasteries thought the Irrawaddy Delta. But the huge casualty figures have been impossible to grasp imaginatively.
On Monday morning, the official figure was 351 dead; that evening, it had risen to 10,000. The next day it was 22,500, followed by estimates by aid workers and diplomats of up to one hundred thousand. It is a struggle to contemplate the meaning of such figures – and the dead were nowhere to be seen in the villages and towns through which I had travelled for two days. But they were there, of course, many of them undisturbed since their deaths, in the deep reaches of the vast delta. And the bodies I saw on my boat ride yesterday were only the ones obviously visible from the river. For every one of them, I would guess that there are half a dozen others hidden out of sight in the narrow creeks and ditches and paddy fields.
Many people survived the cyclone, of course, and on this stretch of river they live as neighbours to the dead. Close by my twelfth corpse, and my twenty-third and twenty-fourth dead buffalo, a group of children were bathing in the river and a woman was washing clothes in front of the shell of a storm-broken village hall. “We pulled many bodies of the people we knew out of the water,” the boatman, Myint Swa said. “There were ten babies, all from this village and we buried those in the cemetery.”
But the storm surge carried people and debris from all over the area. The bodies floating in the water are just the ones whom no one has claimed or no one can recognise – part of the 41,000 [CHECK FIGURE] designated as “missing” by the Burmese government. Or perhaps they are simply from families of whom not a single member survived.
The survivors live on exist in a wretched state, and the journey down the Pyapon river confirms what has become ever more clear with every day spent in the Irrawaddy Delta – the vicious indifference of the Burmese dictatorship to he welfare of its own citizens. Almost no one here has received any aid whatsoever, and that which has been delivered is derisory in its insignificance.
Kwagyi is a village on a river island which is so low and exposed that during the twelve hours of Cyclone Nargis’s spate, it ceased to be an island at all. The waters were six half feet high; they covered everything except the buildings, and many of those had been blown away. “When one house fell down, the people ran to the next house that has not fallen down,” said the Venerable Wimsala, abbot of the small monastery on the island. “And then when that one fell down they ran to another one.”
The monastery’s meditation room collapsed, killing Miss Wain, the schoolmistress, who was inside, praying for her life. Dozens of other villagers died. Today, the community survives on coconuts (of all trees, the palm was the one most resistant to the storm). One in seven villagers is suffering from diarrhoea and the children are succumbing to fevers. But no representative of the government has been here to offer the villagers help or even to assess their need.
“The government officials go to the town, but they do not come here,” says the Venerable Wimsala, although that is not quite true. In Myinkakon village, a little way upstream every single family in the village received one pi of rice yesterday – one pi for each of 200 families. Such munificence is in danger of sounding impressive until you learn what the Burmese measure of a pi represents – it is a single level scoop, about as much as could be contained in an empty baked bean can, enough to feed just one person for two meals.
The government is overwhelmed by the scale of the tragedy, as most governments would be – think of the chaos of the early days after Hurricane Katrina hit New Orleans. But that is no excuse for the current state of affairs. In granaries and store houses across the region are food and medical supplies which could be flown to Burma within hours and dispensed to the villages of the delta within days. One thing, and thing alone, holds them up – the Burmese government’s refusal to give the necessary permissions to foreign aid workers.
It is not just the food itself, but the entire logistical operation that requires outside help. According to a recent visitor to Rangoon airport, there are so few forklift trucks that the little aid that has arrived has to be unloaded by hand by an exhausted troop of 300 soldiers. Foreign diplomats in Rangoon report that the government has at its disposal only seven helicopters but, from the available evidence, these are not being used for serious aid work. Instead, the generals use them for a series of photo opportunities, which duly appear in the following morning’s state run press.
In one, the prime minister, Thein Sein, is pictured “assisting” the loading of relief supplies onto a helicopter; in another a junior minister, hands over a bag of rice to a scared looking but “grateful” cyclone victim. The accompanying news stories achieve the feat of making the country’s worst disaster in living memory seem like nothing more than a bothersome inconvenience.
In the most staggering image of all, Mr Thein Sein “presented 20 sets of TV, 10 DVD players and 10 satellite receivers … for the storm victims enabling them to enjoy the programmes”. It would be hilarious if it were not so depressing: having survived the destruction of their homes, the deaths of their loved ones, and lacking food or medicines, the cyclone survivors are being forced to watch Burmese state television.
Cyclone Nargis had been forming for days; the government was warned that it could be gravely destructive, and days before it struck the United Nations agencies were drawing up the same emergency plans which they are now forbidden from implementing. But everyone one meets in the delta says the same thing: apart from a forecast of choppy weather, there was no warning of the scale of the cyclone or any advice about to do to protect against it.
Myint Swa the boatman climbed a palm tree and hung on for dear life. His wife and eight children cowered in the boat and rode out the boiling waters. Many had no such recourse; now they lie bobbing in the water like pieces of rotting meat. Burma’s generals have oppressed their people for so long that their brutal incompetence had ceased to be news. But this week they have has added a whole new chapter to the book of their crimes.
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£100k
The National Skills Academy for Social Care
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
£75k - £85k
Confidential
London
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
$3.5 million
Also avaliable for rent
Times Online Property Search will help you find it
Amazing Far East Offers - Visit Hong Kong
from £499pp
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
To Lim, Malysia
Please would you address people properly and not rudely. You do yourself and your pan-asian cause a great disservice.
Boris, Belgravia, London
Maitreya points out that when disasters occur on an international scale, people await a second coming. But the Lord has been here since the morning of time.
Zuni, Buenos Aires, Argentina
Sun, Swansea, Wales
Sun, there is nothing wrong with China for selling arms to Myanmar. The Western countries are even bigger sellers of arms. If you are happy staying in UK, just stay on. China has 1.4 billion loyal citizens. One less makes no difference.
U can change country but not your DNA
Lim, Johor Bahru, Malaysia
I am so ashame of my country China for selling weapons to Burma regime. This not right thing to do. I stay in UK now for job and life and no go back to China. I feel so sorry for my father he being tricked to think life ok. I pay for him to come here now.
Sun, Swansea, Wales
Discussing the sovereignty of the country in the UN security council in the middle of humanitarian crisis is just stupid...
UN should allow all the aid in without the approval from the government who illegally took over the power from the people...
I really wish US invade my country now...
Lin, Yangon, Myanmar
After reading this news report I am angry that the U.N. is standing by and letting this happen. It is obvious that the Burmese Junta does not care about the people. The U.N. should step up and do whatever it takes to get relief to these people. If they can't perform then lets dislove the U.N.
Wayne Doak, Ottawa Ontario, Canada
Congratulations on a great article.
The reporter has obviously risked his life to get into Burma to report on this extremely serious and sad event.
I hope we all will be able to help the needy and ill and be able to demonstrate our humanity.
Miguel Sanchez, Alicante, Espana
Patricia,I think you'll find that the US has more of a history of creating humanitarian crises rather than solving them....besides, when you couldnt mobilise enough national guardsmen to deal with the aftermath of Katrina, how are you going to solve a problem like this approx 10,000miles away?
patrick, The Hague, netherlands
Why don't our military helicopters just start dropping food and medical supplies? We don't have to land and there is no way the Junta can stop or interfere with supply drops!
Mary Mathis, Ormond Beach, FL, USA
shelly shen, Jinhua Zhejiang, China
Beautifully stated. The Chinese Govt had been very effective in dealing with disasters. Hope the Myanmar Govt will follow China's good example and urgently help its people now without delay. There is reason to hold back help and aid desperately needed.
Lim, Johor Bahru, Malaysia
Goes to show that for China/ASEAN, the opportunity to trade/mine precious stones outweighs the life of one million ordinary folk.
David , London,
The US could step in and remove this brutal Burmese regime in five minutes. Then everyone in the world would be cheering except for their equally brutal profiteering big neighbour, and we all know who they are. Have a happy Olympics everyone.
Boris, Belgravia, London
The Burmese would rather starve than accept American aid. How right of them. As much as anyone else - perhaps more - they have witnessed American 'aid' in Vietnam, Cambodia and Iraq, and the mass slaughter by Americans in these countries. They will not have villages bombed 'in order to save them'.
Andrew May, De Panne, Belgium
The worthlessness of the UN in the face of the suffering of people of North Korea, Iraq, Rwanda, and Darfur is astonishing. If people were truly concerned, they would be calling for direct, force-backed intervention. But, that might involve the hint that Bush was right to act in Iraq.
Nick, Rotherham, UK
This will go down in history books , as an example of how coward , indifferent and business minded leaders of the so-called civilized nations are. There is no doub t that people there are suffering , every minute counts , and we pretty wel know that, but these leaders will not act.
Bhaskar Gollapudi, London,
The less survivors, the less opposition in the running of some "election". That's the junta strategy.
lauren, London , Uk
The U.N. is merely an excuse for the leaders of the world to get together and feel important--to congratulate themselves for being so great. Clearly, when it comes to matters of mass human death (Rwanda, Burma) they are unable, or unwilling to sacrifice the lives of their countrymen to save others
Tim, Philadelphia, USA
This just goes to show the UN is all talk. It's failing the Burmese people like it failed the Rawandans and the Somalians. People are dying while they draft a letter saying how angry they are with the Burmese Junta. And I blame countries like China that's supporting an illegitimate such as this.
Kyaw, Sydney, Australia
Even if we don't invade fully, why don't we just send in our own helicopters with some marines strapped in and hand the aid out ourselves.
Sovereignty means nothing in the face of such overwhelming suffering and such uncaring cruelty.
James, Nottingham,
What use the UN ?
Ian Payne, WALSALL,
I got quite annoyed after reading this piece of news; I think the govt. should be blamed. Instead of doing something superficial, they need to take real and practical measures to solve the problem. I think the Chinese govt. set a good example in the case of disaster, like the snow crisis at the beginning of the Chinese traditional New Year. I really think that the govt. should be the one of the people, by the people, the most important, for the people.
shelly shen, Jinhua Zhejiang, China
I got quite annoyed after reading this piece of news; I think the govt. should be blamed. How can they just sat back and watched without going to rescue the people in desperate state. Instead of doing something superficial, they need to take real and practical measures to solve the problem. I think the Chinese govt. set a good example in the case of disaster, like the snow crisis at the beginning of the Chinese traditional New Year. I really think that the govt. should be the one of the people, by the people, the most important, for the people.
shelly shen, Jinhua Zhejiang, China
But the UN cannot take action without the consent of the Burmese Govt. Otherwise it would be showing otal disregard for sovereignty. We need states like China, Thailand and India to put increasing pressure on the junta. Maybe once todays election is over they will conceed defeat? One would hope so.
Elizabeth Nuttall, London, UK
Send in a UN force now...or have the blood of 100,000+ people on your hands. A large co-ordinated force would take the airport and provide a base to deliver relief to the people. There are no visas coming and never will be. Time is running out!
Chris Coombes, Chiang Mai, Thailand
It is easy 4 West 2 blame d govt. for lack of response 2 warning on cyclone. I am not defending d govt. but cld it be that thse farmers/people hesitated to evacuate their homes. They had not experienced such violent storms b4. In Indonesia, people refused to leave homes inspite of volcano warning
Lim, Johor Bahru, Malaysia
I agree with Patricia. If the rest of the world really cared about these people, they would all show some guts and go into Burma without the permission of the Burmese government. Sometimes you have to do things you don't want to do. More rain is coming and it's going to get worse.
Terry A., Lodi, NJ, USA
If they only have seven helicopters let's invade. This is a humanitarian crisis, a world problem. There is no value for life with the junta. What religion are they? Not Buddists.
Patricia Murphy, Charleston, USA