AA Gill at the Republican convention
Get 20% off your bill at Pizza Express

So hi there. Welcome to Pig’s Eye, Minnesota. Funny old name. Funny old place. Minnesota. It’s Indian for “wrap up warm”. The Sioux used to say, “We’re going to Pig’s Eye” and their mother would say, “Minnesota”. And then, as so often happens, the religious right came along and spoilt everything. And changed Pig’s Eye to St Paul and told everybody to go to bed at 7pm and feel guilty.
St Paul is the state capital, although nobody knows that. Everyone thinks it’s Minneapolis next door. They call them the Twin Cities and St Paul suffers from sibling envy. Minneapolis is bigger, louder and picks up loose women. Minneapolis used to be called All Saints, but to stick it back to the Catholics they renamed it Minneapolis, which is Indian for “I’m not wearing any knickers”.
The Republicans chose St Paul for their convention because, like Colorado, Minnesota is a swing state. It doesn’t swing very far and it doesn’t swing very often and it doesn’t swing in a way that is exciting. This is where the Swedes and Norwegians came to try to whittle Scandinavia out of the hem of Canada. Back home they grew to be the most liberal nations in the world. Here they grew silent and maudlin. There’s a Minnesotan joke – only the one. It goes like this: there was an old Norwegian man who loved his wife so much he almost told her. That was so funny I almost laughed.
Minnesotans are hard, dour, diligent Calvinists with handmade virtues, genetic stoicism and long underwear. They boast a state characteristic called “Minnesotan nice”, and they are. They have an unrelenting, unwavering, unvarying and unquestioning niceness.
The convention is a nice, lacklustre affair. It starts badly with an empty hall, cancelled on the first day in deference to Hurricane Gustav. So we have to spend Monday finding out interesting things about Minnesota. The state mushroom is a morel. The state drink is milk. I’m not making this up. The state grain is wild rice. The state fish is the walleye. Its bird is the loon. Minnesota has the world’s smallest carnivore, the least weasel, but no one’s ever seen it. Each year the 11 prettiest farm girls are sculpted in butter and exhibited in a rotating fridge. I know – the excitement.
St Paul doesn’t quite boast – because boasting isn’t very Minnesotan – the largest shopping mall in the world. A perky, peachy girl told me that if you spend just three minutes in every shop, it would take you three days to get round. If you spend three days in this mall, you’d need a straitjacket and intravenous opiate.
There was one thing that I quite liked. It was a T-shirt among the otherwise dull McCain memorabilia. On it was the face of Barack Obama superimposed on Mr Spock. The similarity’s quite spooky, what with the predominant ears. Obama Vulcan is giving the Star Trek salute and saying, “Live long and prosper”, which could be a quote from one of his speeches.
You see what they’ve done there? It underlines, exaggerates and emphasises his otherness. He’s clever, but he’s alien. Only half-human. Half-extraterrestrial. And the thing that stopped Obama being just another skinny lawyer from Illinois is his blackness. The symbolism couldn’t have been any clearer if the face had been projected onto Al Jolson.
The elephant is the Republicans’ totem animal and the great pachyderm in this ice-hockey stadium is blackness. Nobody mentions it. It isn’t in speeches or off-the-record background briefings, but it’s just the constant humming theme, like a distant generator. The Republicans’ bottom-line strategy, their last hope, is that, when all alone in a voting booth, enough Americans in enough states won’t make a black man president. They’re not racist. They’ve seen it on TV and in Hollywood. But in real life, the commander-in-chief has gotta be a white dude.
At this convention the Republicans have just 36 black delegates. That is perhaps the most shocking statistic of the whole election. That’s less than 2% of all the delegates. Fewer than one per state and less than any other election for 40 years. THOSE are the interesting things that I found out on Monday and Tuesday. But on Wednesday everything changes. It all gets Technicolor with sprinkles on top and it comes back to the subject closest to Republican hearts: sex. Sex and the young. Hot, procreative sex.
Sarah Palin is making the keynote speech. She has flown in from Alaska with her family. The announcement that this obscure governor is going to be the vice-presidential nominee has propelled the convention into the biggest, kitschest reality show in the world. The relations and the speculation about paternity, maternity, fecundity, mendacity and the gestation period for Eskimos has led to a Gustav of schadenfreude that has overwhelmed the shallow blogs on the web. Sarah’s womb is the black hole into which the best laid plans of the Republican party have disappeared.
Depending on how fundamentally hard right you are, Palin is either a godsend who speaks to the experience of ordinary small-town large-breasted American women and sticks two fingers in the eyes of the coastal latte liberals. Or she’s a hideously embarrassing mistake that will swamp the election in underclass redneck sexual incontinence and that everything is about damage limitation and trying not to think about what would happen if President McCain died and this was the first family. Not so much from igloo to White House as igloo to White Trailer.
The convention does what it knows its heroes Teddy Roosevelt, Ronald Reagan and Arnold Schwarzenegger (in Terminator, not Kindergarten Cop) would have done: they charge. Mitt Romney and Mike Huckabee make vicious ankle-biting speeches. Rudy Giuliani gives the speech of his life, a sustained rant of spittle-flecked invective, innuendo and verbal cage-fighting.
Giuliani is Republican road rage. He is also a Republican road wreck: pro-gay marriage and abortion, with a private life that would get bleeped off Jerry Springer. But he tees up Sarah’s speech. (We all know her as Sarah, because this is so like morning agony television.) Entering with her family, she has a “throw the snowmobile keys into the fur hat” sled-dogging look to her. The naughty smirk of the killer librarian. There’s a whiff of baby oil and moose blood, a heady pheromone that rouses delegates to waggle their paunches at her.
She has been given a speech that is as well oiled and finely crafted as a synchronised beaver trap. It’s very aggressive. It goes for the throat of liberals and Obama. It mocks and it ridicules. And some of it hits home. It’s good for the room. They cheer to the echo. But outside, down the unforgiving prurient tube, I think she looks hard and calculating and a bit of a bitch. I can imagine people all over the country saying, I wouldn’t want her for my mom. The first poll seems to indicate that she loses a vote for every one she wins.
At the centre of the week’s fetid speculation on the blogosphere about Sarah is a baby. He’s sweet and flaccid and beautifully behaved. And even if Sarah is not prepared to keep her family out of politics, at least Trig Palin is serenely keeping himself out. He’s passed backwards and forwards through sisters and father and brothers and then on to Cindy McCain – a bizarre Dynasty character in mad woman’s lime. People come up and pat him and coo at him and he just looks beatific and comforted. He is the eye of the storm. And it reminds me of a paraphrase of Hillary Clinton: it takes a whole Republican party to bring up a child.
Yet the most sustained excitement of the week isn’t for Trig or Sarah or even McCain, or sticking it to Barack. It’s for oil. For self-sufficiency. For cutting the umbilical pipeline with the eyeball-eating, terrorist-funding Middle East and the commie gangsters of Latin America and Russia. Let the world wallow in its own sump and turpitude. America needs to drill, drill for its dream. The marvellously priapic image of getting the bit between the loins had them chanting, then shouting, then roaring: “Drill baby, drill baby, drill baby, drill.” THURSDAY, the last day, belongs to McCain. This is when he accepts the nomination. Before he starts there are problems. The Republicans have used all their best speakers – Romney, Huckabee, Giuliani – to bolster the vice-presidential nominee. Today all we’re offered are a couple of old mates you’ve never heard of and a millionaire Nascar owner who got evangelism along with money and delivers a buttock- clenching motivational speech as a bone for the religious right: “Let God be your team’s coach and play to his game plan.”
A couple of political cronies bang on about the military. The Republicans’ lachrymose fondling of the services is weird. Any mention of boys in Iraq incites instant whoops and stomping cheers from the floor. It’s the easiest, cheapest applause and it’s at odds with the long American tradition of a citizens’ militia, raised reluctantly, and of arms borne modestly.
Cindy McCain is sent in to secure the podium for her man. She is another brilliantly weird woman, a second wife who started her affair with him just after he had separated from his first. She is the heiress of a beer fortune with cloudy origins. She has devoted her life to impressively hands- on charitable work in the developing world, extreme beauty treatments and part-time drug abuse.
A short and selective film of her life reveals a woman who has modelled herself on Diana, Princess of Wales. There are photographs of her with black babies and Mother Teresa that look like Alison Jack-son spoofs.
From Mother T she adopted a Bangla-deshi baby, Bridget, now a plump teenager who is paraded on stage with all the other kids.
The hall never quite fills up. It has been a long and dreary week. Everybody’s old. Dinner was at six. And it’s getting close to bedtime. As McCain walks onto the stage to accept the ovation, he begins by thanking George Bush. There’s a bit of a gasp. This is the first time the president has been mentioned.
It’s a reminder that all the things the Republicans claim they will change in Washington are a result of eight years of Republican government. The hard right is more comfortable being the opposition. It finds having to take responsibility for things full of awkward contradictions.
McCain stands in front of a great green screen that makes him look like the undead, which in so many ways he is. The years in captivity, the cancer and age have made a mess of him. He can’t lift his arms above his shoulders. He walks like a man who’s been bayoneted in the groin. He is a man who’s been bayoneted in the groin. But most worrying is his head, which behaves like a rejected muppet.
The expressions bear little relation to the words. His mouth can spring into a child’s terrifying rictus grin at random intervals. One eye winks lasciviously as if it were out on the pull on its own and he has the voice of a cartoon character: reedy and softly sibilant, the tone of an anthropomorphic vole.
The speech is a calamity. He rambles and confuses sentence endings with beginnings, he punctuates tentatively and emphasises arbitrarily. There is no story, no thread, no interest. He loses contact with the audience who are distracted by a couple of angry war demonstrators. They chant “USA, USA” into the gods like a losing football crowd. McCain blinks and grins and slaps. It’s not good. When he actually gets to tell his own tough story of captivity, it’s a ho-hum anticlimax. We’ve all heard it a dozen times already this week.
Finally, the desperate, bored crowd, who want to see the balloons, give him a standing ovation before he has finished, drowning out the last paragraphs. Even as he’s thumbs-upping mates on the floor, the blogs are assassinating him: “The worst acceptance speech since Jimmy Carter.”
Cindy’s back on stage, elongated, polished and blonde, the apotheosis of Barbie. He is an abused puppet. And then they’re joined by Palin, all too human. McCain seems to shrink between these two compellingly spectacular tabloid women.
It has been Palin’s convention, the pit-bull Bovary. There is the brassy glow of nemesis about her, a delicious hint of salty revelations to come. Parts of the nation are addicted to soap opera drama and blue-collar tragedy and they will cling to her. She waves into the spotlight, naughty and manipulative and defiant.
Someone comments that Palin should drop McCain from the ticket. He stands there, stiff and twitching, with his skull grin, a good man, a decent, humane and committed man, fated by bad luck. It is his destiny to be in the wrong place at the wrong time, to fall from a great height into the hands of bad people. The balloons gently, mockingly, carpet bomb the stage.

Obama's victory night and his rise to the White House
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£100k
The National Skills Academy for Social Care
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
£75k - £85k
Confidential
London
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
$3.5 million
Also avaliable for rent
Times Online Property Search will help you find it
Amazing Far East Offers - Visit Hong Kong
from £499pp
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I have a question for everyone out there. Is the party you vote part of your identity? I find it odd that so many Republicans tend to be so personally locked up in a party system, and violent towards liberals and independents. Democrats seems less 'locked-in' , and for this usually considered weak.
katy, idaho, U.S.A.
Thank you. Oh how I wish we could read something like this in the American mainstream press. I will send this to friends and ask them to skip over the first part about Minnesota.
M. Lewis, New York, NY, USA
What a brilliantly written column. We Americans wonder why much of the civilized world hates us...and then we parade that repulsive convention....to take away all doubt. Please, please, if there IS a God, he MUST step in to make sure there isn't another arrogant administration like the last one.
Hugh, Waco, U.S.
Nothing of Governor Sarah Palin's acceptance speech disturbed me more than when she sarcastically mocked the reading of their civil rights to suspects of terrorism. Was I the only one to hear this? I wonder, would she and Senator McCain rather win an election than save the Constitution?
Robert, New York City,
What a brilliant piece of writing on the characteristics of Palin, McCain and the whole RNC. So true - hits the nail on the head - now, if only people could come to their senses and see how far this country has slid in terms of our inability to see what is really happening to us - chilling.
Jessica Stensrud, Pawtucket, USA
What a illuminating view from Europe. Absurd, nihilistic and chilling: just the way many women feel about this ticket choice. It would be hilarious if the stakes weren't so high. Our future begins to echo another country's in 1938.
Susan, Nevada City, USA
This race is like a cartoon.
"Parts of the nation are addicted to soap opera drama and blue-collar tragedy and they will cling to her." This is amazing. We cannot believe what has happen to us.
victor R, Massachusetts, USA
Fabulous article and just what I was looking for: an outside perspective on the outracious, sad comedy that has become the Republican party. A state of mind where knee-jerk Walmart values (gays bad, abortion evil, women only good for babies and a good time) are more important than everything else.
Lisa, Los Angeles, USA
To the author of this, well written mate!
Just one question that us non americans need answerd though. When are we going to be able to vote? This is a matter that clearly considers us as well! Go Obama!
Freddie, Gothenburg,
Forget the moose-hunting etc. Are we seriously going to accept the potential leader of the free world believing in creationism?
A J McIrvine, London,
"If any woman votes this ticket, they deserve what they get--NOTHING!!"
They will actually get far worse than nothing - worse case scenario is that McCain dies and we have President Palin for almost 12 years - she locks in a supreme court and the rest will be disaster.
Sven, Los Angeles, USA
Great article. A shame we don't have such intelligent analysis on this side of the pond
kurt, nyc, USA
I agree with you completely!! Women have fought for so long to have their rights. If I ever considered voting for McCain, I would never do it now. If any woman votes this ticket, they deserve what they get--NOTHING!! I was starting to consider Mccain but Palin completely irritates me!!
Bern, Bel Air, USA
USA Today/Gallup 9/5-7 MCCAIN 54 OBAMA 44 10 MCCAIN!
so much for this articles evaluative qualities
LNAB, okc, U.S.
Excellent coverage of both Conventions. I enjoyed them very much.
Adrian Anthony Wynter, London, England
wow... are the left really this petty??
so go ahead keep up all you whinning it is only going to hurt you on the left.
Bobbi, tucson, USA
Did any of you Republicans notice that this article trashed your party? Are you complete nimrods?
Mark, Shepherdstown, US
Well written, AA GIll!
Jimbo, Los Angeles, usa
Paline gave a great speech but the star of the convention, in my opinion was Mike Huckabee. He gave perhaps one of the best speeches I have ever heard, staying focused on the issues Republicans (in fact all Americans) care about, inspiring, drawing at the emotions, motivating and rallying the party
Linda, Myrtle Beach, USA
One of the best reviews of the GOP gathering in St, Paul.
A good realistic and skeptical view of some of the spin and left out facts from some inconvenient truths about the state of the union. Most curious was McCain running against the very party he was addressing. And there were the cheerleaders.
Gunther Steinberg, Portola Valley CA, USA
Sarah should be the president in 4 years
go & get them girl
God bless sarah & Family
Pat
Patricia Burjony, New Port Richey , FL, USA
Hillarious! Well written.
Mark, New York,